Patient Engagement
Talk
Value-Based Insurance Design: Theory vs. Practice (04:23)

Compelling literature backs up the idea of basing co-payments on the clinical value of a service. However, broader adoption of this strategy is complicated by several barriers, according to Niteesh Choudhry, Executive Director of the Center for Healthcare Delivery Sciences at Brigham and Women’s Hospital.

The first is figuring out which services to apply this concept to and the basic details of their design. Value-based insurance design has thus far been almost exclusively applied to drugs, but there are a number of other services to consider for cost sharing, such as non-drug therapeutics.

“Perhaps the greatest benefit or potential benefit of this idea of basing co-payments on value would be achieved by raising co-payments for those things that are of low value,” says Choudhry. “If we’re really going to drive economic value, that’s where it would come [from].”

“Equally important when it comes to applying value-based insurance design in practice is that we need to really be thoughtful about how we do it,” adds Choudhry. “So if you’ve seen one value-based insurance program you’ve seen exactly one value-based insurance program.”

Second, because most health care in the U.S. is employer sponsored, insurance is often fragmented: employees change employers frequently, and employers change insurers frequently. Employers and insurers may therefore be reluctant to adopt value-based insurance strategies. “We need to think thoughtfully about how to create incentives for employers to actually do this in the short run,” says Choudhry.

Lastly, Choudhry says, we need to do a better job of targeting who we use this strategy for. Much of the improvement in adherence resulting from these strategies has come from patients who had already been adherent. “There are small improvements in adherence for the population as a whole and many patients who did not actually respond at all,” notes Choudhry. “So as we move forward for this quality improvement intervention or any of the wide varieties in benefit design or broader into technology, we need to do a much better job of making this trade-off.”

From the NEJM Catalyst event Patient Engagement: Behavioral Strategies for Better Health at the University of Pennsylvania, February 25, 2016. Watch Part 1 of Niteesh Choudhry’s talk: An Alternative Approach to Insurance Design.

More From Patient Engagement
PROMs Usage Is Limited but Growing

Patient Engagement Buzz Survey: PROMs Use Is Growing, but Implementation Takes Effort

While clinical outcomes lend themselves to measurement, quantifying how an individual patient experiences symptoms or a loss of function can be more challenging. One promising approach is the use of Patient-Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs).

Taxonomy of the Patient Voice Table

Taxonomy of the Patient Voice

While health care pursues the important trend of putting patients at the center of care, the terms used to describe this goal are proliferating — and muddying the discourse. This taxonomy attempts to classify some of these terms and make some distinctions.

Agarwal01_pullquote handcrafting the patient experience

Handcrafting the Patient Experience

Health care organizations can take cues from consumer-facing companies like Airbnb to creatively insert convenience and surprise into patient encounters.

Screenshot of Tidepool daily diabetes data

A Taxonomy to Engage Patients: Objectives, Design, and Patient Activation

Health information initiatives will succeed only if they focus on patients’ motivation to engage and reflect the type of engagement they seek.

Ghafur01_pullquote -digital health health care consumer patient experience

Engaging Patients Using Digital Technology — Learning from Other Industries

Providers can benefit patients and disrupt health care by learning from the experience of other industries.

Mission Hospital Virtual Sitter - Drawing of the Virtual Bed Zone and Rails

Reducing Inpatient Falls and Injury Rates by Integrating New Technology with Workflow Redesign

How Mission Hospital scaled a virtual sitter pilot and reduced unassisted falls by 44% and fall-related injuries by 40%.

Health Care Providers Should Incentivize Patients

Survey Snapshot: Patient Financial Incentives — There Are No Quick Fixes

The NEJM Catalyst Insights Council agrees that while financial incentives are a common strategy to engage patients in healthy behaviors, they are not necessarily effective.

Support of Family and Friends Is More Effective Than Clinician Support in Realizing Health Goals - From the Patient Engagement Insights Report: Why No Single Health Incentive Works.

Patient Engagement Survey: Why No Single Health Incentive Works

Initiatives to improve patient engagement come in a variety of forms. While insurers, employers, and health care providers are all involved in using financial incentives and penalties for engagement efforts, improvement in health outcomes has been elusive. Achieving that ultimate goal will usually require a combination of financial and social approaches.

Health Systems Attending the Nudge Units in Health Care Symposium - Penn Medicine

Key Insights on Launching a Nudge Unit within a Health Care System

Leaders are finding that making higher-value choices easier through subtle changes to choice architecture can have an outsized impact on medical decision-making.

Barriers to Providing an Oustanding Patient Experience

Buzz Survey Report: Patient Experience

An independent NEJM Catalyst report sponsored by University of Utah Health on barriers to achieving an excellent patient experience.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Patient Incentives

75 Articles

Taxonomy of the Patient Voice

While health care pursues the important trend of putting patients at the center of care,…

Ripe for Disruption: Why and How…

For big tech companies like Amazon, Apple, and Google, the health care sector looks ripe…

Patients As Customers

141 Articles

Information Asymmetry: The Untapped Value of…

The knowledge and preferences that patients could — and should — share with clinicians would…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now