New Marketplace
Clip
Primary Care ACO Models: Way of the Future? (04:31)

“Our competition is inertia,” says Oak Street Health Chief Medical Officer Griffin Myers. “We would welcome more people to get into the space.” Myers adds that “it’s not that scary” and encourages people to look at the Oak Street model as an opportunity. Primary care–led accountable care organizations are the ACO models that have performed the best, which should give people confidence. “Downside risk is downside risk. It’s not your life,” he adds. “If you do all the stuff that we know is right — create access to primary care, medications, and behavioral health services — you’ll go a long way to taking that downside risk off.”

For far too long we’ve looked at value and prestige as being in a big hospital, but “folks in the community taking care of people in their neighborhoods is something equally valuable and deserves equal prestige,” says Myers.

Harvard health policy expert and internist Michael McWilliams views the role of primary care–led, ACO-like practices a bit differently. Evidence shows these practices and independent physician group models generate more savings in these models because “primary care works.” It’s the primary care practices that have the greatest incentive to reduce use of just about any service, particularly hospitalizations. Voided costs are much greater than for hospitals, and the incentives are much stronger for these groups.

“It may be that what we’re seeing in terms of savings is really driven more by utilization management, which is masquerading as care coordination, those practices reducing use of post-acute care and SNFs [skilled nursing facilities] and decreasing admission rates in a much more utilization management–type fashion,” says McWilliams. “If you look at where the savings are, it’s where you would think that you could pull some crude levers to shift patients away from pricey hospital outpatient departments, or reduce admission rates, or reduce admission rates to SNFs, in particular.”

“Perhaps what Griffin has to do to convince you of his model is he can call it waste reduction,” says Harvard Health Care Initiative Chair Robert Huckman, “and the waste is the hospitalizations that he’s avoiding by engaging in this activity.”

Myers agrees with McWilliams, however. “What you must believe is that you’re preventing hospitalizations that were needed,” he says. “That being said, if what you are doing is managing illness so that people don’t have exacerbations and that’s the avoidance, I think that’s a very different question.”

“To be clear, the care coordination, care management programs that lower those rates may successfully lower those rates, but they’re costly,” adds McWilliams, “so then the net savings is a little less certain than the care coordinator who is in charge of making sure patients . . . can go home.”

From the NEJM Catalyst event Navigating Payment Reform for Providers, Payers, and Pharma, held at Harvard Business School, November 2, 2017.

More From New Marketplace
Robert Gavin head shot

Amazon and CVS: Short-Lived Unicorns in Health Care, or Healers of the “Tapeworm”?

Will Amazon–Berkshire Hathaway–JP Morgan and CVS-Aetna change the health care game? To one health care employer purchaser, these announcements feel a lot like Groundhog Day.

Fiona Scott Morton head shot

We Can’t Spend All Our Money on Health Care

We have to think about how much we want to spend on health according to how much it’s worth to us at the margin.

Simplified Chain of Production for Primary Care Services Generating Retail Prescriptions. Solid arrows indicate contractual relationships or ownership, and the dashed arrow indicates referral for prescription.

Does CVS–Aetna Spell the End of Business as Usual?

What might one of the largest mergers in history mean for the health care delivery system?

Lack of Incentive Is Top Barrier to Implementing Value-Based Payment

Survey Snapshot: Payer-Provider Alignment Is Difficult Even for Integrated Organizations

NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members say stronger incentives and better use of analytics could improve alignment.

Kaplan04_pullquote Time to Sink Two Canoe Payment Models Argument

Time to Sink the Two-Canoe Argument

Although the transition from fee-for-service to quality-based payment can leave physicians feeling trapped “with a foot in two canoes” while straddling the two payment methods, there are compelling ethical, professional, and business reasons against rationalizing continued support of fee-for-service medicine.

Mostashari01_pullquote - Medicare Advantage Holds the Key to Reforming the ACO Program

Medicare Advantage Holds the Key to Reforming the ACO Program

Value-based care continues to be the emphasis of federal policymakers, as well as many providers. Aligning Medicare Advantage with ACOs would boost both programs.

Physician Group Practices BPCI Classic Success and Looking Ahead to BPCI Advanced Bundled Payments

Physician Group Practices: Succeeding in Bundled Payments

Physician groups are demonstrating their ability to deliver care in new and innovative ways as part of the nationwide effort to transform health care delivery through value-based payment models. The physician experience and perspective is invaluable and should remain an important component of any shift to value-based care.

How Aligned Are Payers and Providers in Working Together to Achieve Value-Based Care

New Marketplace Survey: Payers and Providers Remain Far Apart

Health care stakeholders are not aligned in important goals and in large part are not working together to achieve value-based care, according to the NEJM Catalyst Insights Council. They are waiting on government regulators to change the payment model — including, possibly, single-payer health care.

Comparison of Select Characteristics of the Sample and Shared Savings Program - MMSP ACO - Physician-Led ACOs

Do Independent Physician-Led ACOs Have a Future?

While some of these smaller organizations are succeeding, they do face numerous challenges, and there is a need for both regulatory change as well as greater sharing of peer-based resources and best practices.

Disruption of Innovative Mergers in Health Care Industry - BDO graphic

Innovative Mergers Will Disrupt Health Care

The NEJM Catalyst Insights Council expects outside players to have a major impact on the industry over the next three years.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

We Can’t Spend All Our Money…

We have to think about how much we want to spend on health according to…

Change the Model → Change the…

If we’re going to change the health care payment model, do we need to change…

Change the Model → Change the…

If we’re going to change the health care payment model, do we need to change…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now