New Marketplace
Clip
Primary Care ACO Models: Way of the Future? (04:31)

“Our competition is inertia,” says Oak Street Health Chief Medical Officer Griffin Myers. “We would welcome more people to get into the space.” Myers adds that “it’s not that scary” and encourages people to look at the Oak Street model as an opportunity. Primary care–led accountable care organizations are the ACO models that have performed the best, which should give people confidence. “Downside risk is downside risk. It’s not your life,” he adds. “If you do all the stuff that we know is right — create access to primary care, medications, and behavioral health services — you’ll go a long way to taking that downside risk off.”

For far too long we’ve looked at value and prestige as being in a big hospital, but “folks in the community taking care of people in their neighborhoods is something equally valuable and deserves equal prestige,” says Myers.

Harvard health policy expert and internist Michael McWilliams views the role of primary care–led, ACO-like practices a bit differently. Evidence shows these practices and independent physician group models generate more savings in these models because “primary care works.” It’s the primary care practices that have the greatest incentive to reduce use of just about any service, particularly hospitalizations. Voided costs are much greater than for hospitals, and the incentives are much stronger for these groups.

“It may be that what we’re seeing in terms of savings is really driven more by utilization management, which is masquerading as care coordination, those practices reducing use of post-acute care and SNFs [skilled nursing facilities] and decreasing admission rates in a much more utilization management–type fashion,” says McWilliams. “If you look at where the savings are, it’s where you would think that you could pull some crude levers to shift patients away from pricey hospital outpatient departments, or reduce admission rates, or reduce admission rates to SNFs, in particular.”

“Perhaps what Griffin has to do to convince you of his model is he can call it waste reduction,” says Harvard Health Care Initiative Chair Robert Huckman, “and the waste is the hospitalizations that he’s avoiding by engaging in this activity.”

Myers agrees with McWilliams, however. “What you must believe is that you’re preventing hospitalizations that were needed,” he says. “That being said, if what you are doing is managing illness so that people don’t have exacerbations and that’s the avoidance, I think that’s a very different question.”

“To be clear, the care coordination, care management programs that lower those rates may successfully lower those rates, but they’re costly,” adds McWilliams, “so then the net savings is a little less certain than the care coordinator who is in charge of making sure patients . . . can go home.”

From the NEJM Catalyst event Navigating Payment Reform for Providers, Payers, and Pharma, held at Harvard Business School, November 2, 2017.

More From New Marketplace
Mechanic02_pullquote self-insured employers

Self-Insured Employers — The Payment-Reform Wild Card

Without more private-sector leadership, U.S. health care will remain stuck in a fee-for-service system for the foreseeable future.

Washington State Health Care Authority Center of Excellence joint replacement elements and outcomes of program produces strong patient experience scores

Improving Care by Redesigning Payment

A state-run center of excellence uses benefit design to improve outcomes while controlling cost.

Alaigh03_pullquote aco and bundled payment co-exist

ACOs and Bundled Payments: How the Two Can and Should Coexist

The integration of primary care and specialty care physicians through adoption of both payment models will lead to synergistic value.

Pham03_pullquote payment and delivery-system reform

Payment and Delivery-System Reform — The Next Phase

To truly redesign a system, one has to take a holistic approach and move multiple levers in concert, rather than fiddling with individual factors serially and hoping for a coordinated effect.

A Connected Health Data and Service Ecoystem - digital health platform convener

Convening a Digitally Enabled Ecosystem to Address the Chronic Disease Burden of an Underserved Community

Disrupted by technologies, health care needs ecosystem-based solutions for integration and equitable access.

Shachar01_pullquote value-based care fee-for-service fraud and abuse laws

Are Fraud and Abuse Laws Stifling Value-Based Care?

To realize the true potential of value-based care, we must update the underlying assumptions in our fraud and abuse regulatory system.

Porter02_SBUs and IPUs pullquote1

What 21st Century Health Care Should Learn from 20th Century Business

Just as there is no such thing as good marketing or good manufacturing, there is no such thing as good primary care — it completely depends on how that care is tailored to meet the needs of patients with a particular medical condition.

Missouri Show Me Health Plans Cost Calculator for Health Insurance Enrollment screen shot - health insurance education

Facilitating Health Insurance Enrollment in an Uncertain Environment

Lessons learned from five years of open enrollment in Missouri.

Birkmeyer02_pullquote - national physician practices NPPs

Aggregators, Innovators, and the Resurgence of National Physician Practices

A perspective on the growth of NPPs and the ideological divide between for-profit and nonprofit providers.

Hospital-based ACOs Key Capabilities Are Different Based on Level of Risk

Hospital-based ACOs Face Challenges in Tracking Performance Indicators

A focus on bundled payments for specific episodes of care — versus the broad changes required in an ACO model — may be a more effective method for ACO participants to develop capabilities required to measure utilization, cost, and revenue metrics.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Payment and Delivery-System Reform — The…

To truly redesign a system, one has to take a holistic approach and move multiple…

Bundled Payments

53 Articles

Improving Care by Redesigning Payment

A state-run center of excellence uses benefit design to improve outcomes while controlling cost.

Improving Care by Redesigning Payment

A state-run center of excellence uses benefit design to improve outcomes while controlling cost.

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now