Care Redesign
Clip
Patient-Provider Conflict: The Perfect Environment (03:54)

Those in the provider community might say, we tried to change the game in the ’80s and ’90s, and it didn’t work. So when it comes to balancing payment reform with putting the patient first, why do we play the same game if we get the same results?

There are fundamental differences between then and now, says Patrick Conway. The majority of the transformation that we see now is provider/physician/clinician driven — and the majority is voluntary. But he thinks we have some work to do with patients, adding that he doesn’t think we’ve done a great job of explaining what this actually means for real people.

“But I think our approach is quite different in terms of really having it be driven by the delivery system,” Conway adds. “And this one we’re going to need to continue to monitor, because if we go too far in the other direction, it doesn’t feel driven by the people in the delivery system, including the patients and providers, and it could have a real negative pushback.”

François de Brantes explains that one area where we failed the last time around is that by reforming payment, we failed to reform benefit design at the same time. “We created a perfect environment for conflict between the patient and the provider,” he says. For example, in the old days of “HMO $5 all-you-can-eat buffets,” patients will choose extra medical care, such as lab tests, because it’s no difference to them. But the provider, appropriately, doesn’t want to give that test because it might be unnecessary, says de Brantes.

“So you have a conflict. And this time around, that’s really a big difference because at least in the commercial sector, the volume of co-pays, the cost-sharing that commercially insured client members have to dish out, really does [create], from many perspectives, a better convergence between the patients’ interests and the providers’ interest,” de Brantes says.

But we also see zone detention. “For example, you can emphasize preventative care — that’s fine, because it’s covered in full. Secondary prevention is a big problem, because of course if the providers are held accountable for excessive ED visits or hospitalization of a patient because it’s a complication, then they’re going to want their patients to be more compliant, they’re going to want the lab tests, and the patients have to pay for all of that out of pocket.”

He adds that this is a growing concern in the commercial sector, because if we don’t figure that piece out, then the conflict remains between the provider, who is deliberately trying to deliver better care to the patient, and patients feeling as though they’re getting “sucked in” to doing a test that they don’t need.

To that end, de Brantes agrees with Conway that we have to do a far, far better job at trying to explain to people what all of this means.

 

From the NEJM Catalyst event Care Redesign: Creating the Future of Care Delivery at Kaiser Permanente Center for Total Health, September 30, 2015.

More From Care Redesign
Consensus That Design Thinking Is Useful in Health Care

Survey Snapshot: Design Thinking Is Useful, So Why Aren’t More People Using It?

NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members agree that design thinking useful, but leadership buy-in and understanding of how to implement it may create barriers.

Artificial Intelligence AI Technologies - 5 Approaches to Augmentation of Health Care Decision-Making

Artificial Intelligence and the Augmentation of Health Care Decision-Making

Artificial intelligence is most likely to improve health care by augmenting the work of human clinicians.

Improving Scores Through Human-Centered Design

Designing and Implementing Better Patient Experiences

An ophthalmology provider with facilities in the greater Mexico City area is using Human-Centered Design to improve both the patient and staff experience.

Joseph04_pullquote_hospital_wellness

Designing Hospitals That Heal as Well as Treat

Hospitals must provide wholesome food, sound sleeping conditions, and human connection to promote healing and wellness.

Health Care Organizations Only Occassionally Apply Design Thinking

Care Redesign Survey: How Design Thinking Can Transform Health Care

Health care leaders and frontline clinicians are eager to embrace design thinking. Yet its principles are not widely applied.

Chernew04_pullquote targeted supplemental data collection

Targeted Supplemental Data Collection — Addressing the Quality-Measurement Conundrum

Targeted supplemental data collection may be a valuable approach to balancing data needs with data-collection costs.

Opioid Prescriptions Strength Conversion Table

Tackling the Opioid Crisis with Clear Prescription Guidelines, Accurate Monitoring, and Provider Education

How a large physician organization reduced the amount of opioids prescribed per patient while increasing referrals for pain management consultation.

David Waters Community Servings CEO

Food as Medicine: Meeting the Needs of Complex Medical Diets

How Community Servings evolved from an HIV nutrition program to one that feeds people with any illness.

HaH-Plus Program Reduces Patient Days Spent in Health Care Facilities in Final 180 Days of Life

Hospital at Home–Plus Reduces Days Spent in Hospitals and Other Inpatient Facilities

Patients enrolled in Mount Sinai Health System’s HaH-Plus program spend about one-third as many days in health care facilities as inpatients in the last 180 days of life.

SLUCare General Internal Medicine Interactive Voice Response - Patient Access

Creating a Holistic Approach to Patient Access

To get beyond simplistic measures such as increased patient appointments or decreased lag days, operations administrators and physician champions must develop effective partnerships.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Moving from a Sickness Model of…

A public health expert discusses the scientific, technological, and financial foundations we need to modernize…

Quality Management

139 Articles

Better Physician Ratings from Discussing PROs…

A UPMC study demonstrates the value of PROs, but finds that physicians need to discuss…

Coordinated Care

113 Articles

Improving Patient Flow with Dynamic Work…

Staff make big improvements in post-operative care by changing small details.

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now