Patient Engagement
Capturing the Patient Voice

Survey Snapshot: Health Care Providers on the Problems of Patient Engagement Design

Insights Report · October 12, 2017

Better patient engagement is a nearly universal goal for health care providers, but real barriers exist, say health care leaders and clinicians. Nearly two-thirds (63%) of respondents to NEJM Catalyst’s latest Insights Council survey on patient engagement call the time investment required by health teams the biggest challenge in designing patient engagement into care delivery.

The underlying issue is reimbursements, says Bertrand Ross, MD, FACC, FACP, Medical Director at Virginia-based Optima Health, a subsidiary of Sentara Healthcare providing health plan coverage to more than 450,000 members. “The problem is that incentives [for patient engagement] are not aligned. The time and effort to educate, motivate, and troubleshoot issues regarding patient engagement are not recompensed very well at present.” Create alignment, he says, and the time investment challenge will disappear.

Historically, Ross says, doctors have been somewhat hesitant to do the extra work to support patient engagement. “Doctors to some degree worry the changes will be too disruptive. How will physicians blend patient engagement into their [care delivery] workflow?” he says. For instance, he considers telehealth and telemedicine the future of care delivery and a form of patient engagement. Yet the valuation of the service is still up in the air because of the workflow changes that will be likely required. “This reimbursement issue is holding adoption back,” he says.

“There used to be a saying amongst waitresses in diners: ‘Not my job, not my table,’” Ross says. “[Physicians] need to realize that patient engagement is our job and our table. We all have to be involved in the design of health care delivery to ensure it works in terms of quality, productivity, and the overall mission.”

Time Is the Biggest Challenge in Patient Engagement Design Solutions into Care Delivery, but Other Challenges Are Close Behind

Patient Engagement Insights Report. Click To Enlarge.

Kathryn Duevel, MD, MS, Medical Director of Quality and Innovation at ACMC Health, a multi-specialty health network with 100 physicians in Minnesota, agrees that incentives are part of the problem with getting physicians more deeply involved in improving patient engagement. Just over half of the survey respondents (52%) cite provider adoption as a challenge in designing patient engagement into care delivery.

Duevel expects the national shift to value-based payment to help. “Larger organizations have the capacity to invest in other processes, such as patient engagement, that don’t contribute directly to the fee-based system,” she says. “As we transition to a value-based system, the value of patient engagement starts to pay off and organizations with fewer resources can make the financial equation necessary to fund patient engagement work.”

Provider engagement is essential to patient engagement, Duevel says. Physicians must be given more time in their day, the tools for patient engagement cannot be onerous, and the results must prove meaningful. “Doctors — primarily primary care docs but also docs in general — are working way too many hours. They are getting crunched from all sides and the burnout rates show it,” she says. “That said, when physicians are given time to think about patient engagement, they think it’s worth it and can help them provide better care. It’s not that they don’t value it, they just don’t know where to fit it in.”

Patient engagement design is still a nascent field, says Marjan Bahador, MD, a critical care physician at Johns Hopkins Medicine, which is a part of Johns Hopkins Health System in Baltimore. “Bringing health to the hands of patients and looking at health problems from patients’ eyes is a new concept for medical professionals.”

Prior to joining Johns Hopkins, Bahador says she spent years studying patient engagement for a large health care software company. She observed a dual problem with patient engagement design: Doctors aren’t trained — either in school or on the job — about why patient engagement is important, and at the same time patients aren’t incentivized to be active participants, beyond improving their own health.

She warns against handing over too much design responsibility to patients, because of their lack of expertise. “Patient engagement design and build should be very much according to patients’ needs and the way patients want it to be done, but health care professionals and IT engineers need to be the ones to build it,” she says.

Patients Are the Most Important Participant by Far in Patient Engagement Design Strategies in Care Delivery

Patient Engagement Insights Report. Click To Enlarge.

Yet 91% of survey respondents say the patient is the most important stakeholder in patient engagement design. Duevel believes that patients don’t need to be design experts to be a vital part of patient engagement design. “There is no one who knows better what the patient is interested in or values than the patient,” she says. “If you don’t have the patient perspective, you won’t be able to get them to effectively take in information.”

 

This Survey Snapshot originally appeared in NEJM Catalyst on June 7, 2017.

New Call for Submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Patient Engagement

The Digital Experience Must Also Be a Human(e) Experience

The most humane experiences happen when we meet patients where they are by designing the types of touch points they want and need.

Hawaii Pacific Health Physician Checklist: Creating a Healing Experience

Transforming the Patient Experience Through the Power of Ritual

Ritual is in fact a primitive checklist: a series of steps that create safety and trust between client and caregiver.

Top Three Most Promising Trends to Capture the Patient Voice

Survey Snapshot: Many Different Channels to Hear the Patient Voice

Commentary from NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members on how to capture the patient voice and make hospital staff hear it.

Empowering Patients Empowers Providers

Why should it be surprising and novel that patient-reported outcomes have such power?

Patient-Reported Outcomes for Shared Decision-Making

Making Patients and Doctors Happier — The Potential of Patient-Reported Outcomes

PRO collection is not only feasible and good for clinical care, but it also may enhance physician satisfaction and prevent burnout.

Patient Voice Roundtable Group

Insights Roundtable Report: Measuring What Matters and Capturing the Patient Voice

From a roundtable discussion and NEJM Catalyst survey, a framework for defining the patient voice and integrating it into care delivery.

A Patient and Family Advisory Council (PFAC) for Quality

A Patient and Family Advisory Council for Quality: Making Its Voice Heard at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center

Though PFAC models abound, metrics on best practices are lacking. One prominent hospital may have found the answer: let those who are the experts at being patients and caregivers lead the way.

Digital Health: USC Virtual Care Clinic

Digital Technology to Engage Patients: Ensuring Access for All

To ensure that we engage the patient groups who have much to gain from the more flexible health care interactions that digital innovation can provide, we must consider issues of computer literacy, access, and trust.

PROMS: Total Knee Replacement - Relief from Knee Pain

Implementing Patient-Reported Outcome Measures

PROMs pioneer shares what’s working in a large health system. Make it easy, make it fast, make it relevant.

Smartlists for Patients: The Next Frontier for Engagement?

Patient-centered checklists, or “Smartlists,” offer the hope of improved outcomes and value to both patients and clinicians.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Quality Management

110 Articles

The Perks and Pitfalls of Quality…

You know what you like in a mobile phone and can compare different models’ quality.…

Patient Incentives

51 Articles

The Power of Social Connectedness

We often don’t consider purpose in life and social connectedness when developing health care programs…

Patients As Customers

90 Articles

The Digital Experience Must Also Be…

The most humane experiences happen when we meet patients where they are by designing the…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now