Leadership

Preventable Deaths in American Hospitals

Article · January 23, 2017

Hospital medical errors are the third leading cause of death in the United States. That’s 700 people per day, notes Steve Swensen. “And most of those have a second victim: the nurses, doctors, social workers, managers, pharmacists involved in their care.”

How big of a factor is this victimization? And what can we do to prevent this tragedy, apart from addressing the cause of the preventable death?

In a Mayo Clinic study with the American College of Surgeons, 8.9% of participating U.S. surgeons reported the belief that they’ve made a major medical error within the last 3 months — and 1.5% believe their error resulted in a patient’s death, according to Tait Shanafelt. “When you think about that for a minute, it’s a staggering number,” Shanafelt says. Suicide ideation doubles in that 3-month window as well, he notes, independent of depression — the risk of which triples. “So when we make mistakes — and all physicians will make mistakes during the course of their career — it has a substantial toll on us. And there’s a strong link there with burnout.”

How do we mitigate that? By having a community of colleagues who support each other. “I just don’t think that people who are not physicians or not in the medical field can really fully understand what that experience is like for a surgeon who believes they’ve made such a mistake, with the exception of their colleagues,” says Shanafelt. “And so those communities need to be built ahead of time.” Mayo Clinic, for example, pays for its physicians to periodically go out for meals together.

Physicians are also often reluctant to seek mental health care for depression and suicidal ideation out of concern it will prevent them from renewing their license. Well-intentioned state licensing boards may ask appropriate questions such as, “Do you have a physical or mental health condition currently that impairs your ability to practice with skill and safety?” Or they may ask fairly draconian questions: “Have you ever experienced depression or been treated for depression at any point during your life?” The latter question has nothing to do with current conditions and impairment, explains Shanafelt, causing many physicians to self-prescribe antidepressants rather than seek care. We need to improve the way we’re asking these questions.

Christine Sinsky adds that, according to a Rand Corporation study, many things, such as EMRs, get in the physician’s way of delivering the best patient care, ultimately leading to physician dissatisfaction. “We have a very hazardous information environment that we’re working in, that well-intended, very potentially powerful tools are still somewhat immature and in unexpected ways have made care more hazardous,” explains Sinsky. We need to protect patients — and physicians — while in “this area of information overload, information underload, information chaos”.

Watch the video:

From the NEJM Catalyst event Leadership: Translating Challenge to Success at Mayo Clinic, June 2, 2016.

New Call for Submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Leadership
Kimberlydawn Wisdom

Lessons in Leadership: Kimberlydawn Wisdom

What disturbs you gives you purpose.

Kevin Rooney head shot

Lessons in Leadership: Kevin Rooney

Think big, but start small: change starts with one patient, one nurse or doctor, and one shift.

Amy Compton-Phillips and Tom Lee head shots

The “Give a Darn” Method for Outcomes Measurement

Providence St. Joseph uses the “give a darn” method to deliver value — what makes a difference to patients makes it on the short list.

Leadership and Vision for a Culture of Safety

Leaders must remain committed for the long term, because creating the vision is insufficient; the work to communicate and sustain that vision never really ends.

New HHS Secretary Alex Azar

Infographic: New HHS Secretary Alex Azar

Alex Azar, former head of Eli Lilly and Company, has been tasked by President Trump to reduce the price of prescription drugs, limit health care regulation, and tackle the opioid epidemic.

Izabela Nowosielski head shot

Lessons in Leadership: Izabela Nowosielski

Being a good leader is about knowing who you are as a person.

Health Care Governance Board Quality Committee Johns Hopkins Medicine Governance Structure and Accountability Process with Inpatient Hospital Area Example

Taking Health Care Governance to the Next Level

To take on the underdeveloped state of accountability in health care, directors need to create a board-level quality committee that functions with the same rigor of governance applied by finance committees.

Atrius Health Empathy Forums Employee Participation and Evaluation

How to Integrate Empathy into Daily Care

Atrius Health initiated a practice-wide transformation to integrate empathy into their daily work.

Why Give It Up? My Late-Career Fellowship

Instead of retiring, a physician in his 70s pursued a fellowship in telehealth and found a piece of the future.

A Look in the Mirror: The Role of Medical Training in Physician Burnout

Any rational actor in today’s medical industrial complex wonders, at times, whether the labor is sensible and the effort sustainable.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Physician Burnout

29 Articles

Lessons in Leadership: Kimberlydawn Wisdom

What disturbs you gives you purpose.

Leading Transformation

178 Articles

Health Plans of the Future Are…

How health plans can take advantage of their position in the ecosystem to connect motivated…

Quality Management

119 Articles

Lessons in Leadership: Kevin Rooney

Think big, but start small: change starts with one patient, one nurse or doctor, and…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now