Care Redesign

Survey Snapshot: What’s Standing in the Way of Care Redesign?

Insights Report · June 1, 2016

We talked to executives, clinical leaders, and clinician members of our Insights Council for a closer look at the major obstacles preventing increased value in care.

 

Understanding the top barriers to improving the value of health care is critical to the transformation of health care delivery. Without clarity about what is standing in the way of value-based care, health care leaders and practitioners will be unable to move forward with clinical practice initiatives and other opportunities outlined in Care Redesign Report: Why Population Health Management is Undervalued.

The top obstacle identified in NEJM Catalyst research to improving the value of care was the fee-for-service payment system, according to 52% of respondents overall, as well as 59% of executives and 63% of clinical leaders participating in the survey. Thomas Yackel, MD, MPH, MS, FACP, CPE, Vice President and Chief Clinical Integration Officer at Oregon Health & Science University in Portland, says that fee-for-service creates a misalignment across health care. “The moral imperative for physicians is to be conservative with the application of health care, while the business imperative is to always do more.” Value-based care, he says, will solve this disparity.

Joel Reich, MD, FACEP, MMM, Senior Vice President for Medical Affairs and Chief Medical Officer at Eastern Connecticut Health Network in Manchester, points out that the fee-for-service system doesn’t align incentives with better long-term health, coordination of care, or managing the social determinants of health. “Fee-for-service says, ‘I did this, so I get paid for this,’” he says. “There is nothing in it financially that would push people to work in a more unified manner.”

He believes reimbursement that is directly tied to care quality, outcomes, and management of the total cost of care will enable alignment of care providers.

Providers should be incentivized to change how they deliver care, he says. In a value-based world, integrated networks would promote healthy eating and activity, use community care managers and home health extensively, and be more likely to take advantage of telehealth, including remote patient monitoring and telepsychiatry, to integrate behavioral health services. “Instead of selling health services, we would truly deliver health,” he says.

Respondents to the NEJM Catalyst survey differed in their perception of the patient role in health care. More than half of clinicians (52%) ranked “lack of patient engagement in improving their own health” as their choice for top barrier. Overall, respondents ranked this as the second greatest obstacle to improving the value of care.

Titus Abraham, MD, an internist at Annapolis (Maryland) Internal Medicine, and the physician manager for the practice, says that while he believes lack of patient engagement is a significant issue, he calls it “a two-way street.” “The role of the doctor has diminished,” he says. “Patients are seeking care from other sources such as the Internet, television programming, and so-called ‘alternative providers.’” Abraham believes the onus is on physicians to be more assertive in finding out why a patient is going elsewhere for care.

“Primary care providers, if adequately knowledgeable themselves, can provide the needed context for information and can provide the needed healthy skepticism and evidence-based thinking to determine the role and value of testing and treatment,” he says.

For instance, when he found out a patient of his who had suffered panic attacks had been consulting other doctors and was scheduled for a coronary catheterization, he asked the patient and his wife to see him first. Abraham recommended the patient see a psychiatrist before the procedure. The patient was later diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder rather than cardiac disease.

The third-greatest barrier to improving the value of care, named by 41% of respondents to the NEJM Catalyst survey, was lack of integration of different types of facilities (such as tertiary and community hospitals and non-acute care). Terrill Theman, MD, Adjunct Professor of Healthcare Systems Engineering at Lehigh University, and a former practicing cardiothoracic surgeon, believes that a lack of accountability has hindered care coordination. “When I was in practice, since I was getting the majority of the fee associated with the illness, I made it my job to integrate that patient’s care and get sign-off from all members of their care team,” Theman says. He experienced a fractured delivery system that left patients feeling like no one took responsibility for them. “They need someone who is captain of the ship to make sure everyone talks to one another and that there is a reasonable treatment plan.”

Theman says value-based care makes him optimistic about the future of care delivery, though the rollout has not been perfect. “At least the Affordable Care Act shook the pot and got us working on solutions.”

Care Redesign Insights Report Chart: Barriers to Improving Value of Care

From the Care Redesign Insights Report: Why Population Health Management Is Undervalued. Click To Enlarge.

New Call for Submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Care Redesign
Patient Outcomes Stratified by Low, Moderate, and High-Risk HEART Score

Improving Emergency Department Care for Low-Risk Chest Pain

How Kaiser Permanente Southern California improved ED standard of practice for possible acute coronary syndrome by adopting an evidence-based clinical decision tool.

Academic Innovations Collaborative Colorectal Cancer Driver Diagram - Leading Transformational Change in Primary Care Delivery

Five Keys to Leading Transformational Change in Primary Care

Lessons learned from a Harvard Medical School intervention to strengthen primary care delivery that emphasized teamwork, reflection, and leadership engagement.

Providing Free Food as a Treatment for Diabetes Yields Improved Outcomes for Patients While Reducing Cost of Care - Fresh Food Farmacy - Geisinger program for addressing food insecurity in patients with diabetes

Prescribing Food as a Specialty Drug

Geisinger’s program of providing free food as a treatment for diabetes yields improved outcomes for patients while reducing the cost of care.

Care Design - The H-Evolution of Intensive Care Units - ICU and Human Care Bundle Human-Centered Care Model

My Favorite Slide: The ICU and the Human Care Bundle

Eight aspects of care to improve ICU management from a human-centered care model.

Ring01_pullquote_ Specialty Musculoskeletal Care Services for the Underserved

Specialty Care for the Underserved

The opening of a new medical school provided impetus to restructure musculoskeletal services to give the safety-net population timely access to needed specialty care.

Levels of Independent Empowered Self-Dialysis

Is “Empowered Dialysis” the Key to Better Outcomes?

Self-dialysis patients enjoy far lower mortality and hospitalization rates and far better attitudes about treatment. But there are hard limits to its adoption.

cognitive load theory implications for health care pullquote

Cognitive Load and Its Implications for Health Care

If we recognize and address the limits of brainpower, we can become better caregivers.

Integrated Care - Most effective means of integrating mental and behavioral health services

Survey Snapshot: Integrated Care Makes Sense — but Barriers Remain

NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members call for integration of mental and behavioral health services with primary care.

Health Inequities Racial/Ethnic Disparities in Health Care - Choosing Wisely Clinician-Led Approach

Reducing Racial/Ethnic Inequities in Care: A Clinician-Led Approach

Using the “Choosing Wisely” campaign against low-value care as a model for addressing health care disparities.

Lee B. Sacks Photo

Halfway to Zero Serious Safety Events

How daily huddles have played a key role in Advocate Health Care’s journey toward zero serious safety events by 2020.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Primary Care

148 Articles

Five Keys to Leading Transformational Change…

Lessons learned from a Harvard Medical School intervention to strengthen primary care delivery that emphasized…

Social Needs

61 Articles

Embedding Health Care in the Community

If we are going to work with local communities, we must humbly acknowledge that we…

Mental Health

18 Articles

Messaging System Helps Caregivers Keep Tabs…

One behavioral health provider pilots cost-effective outreach to patients with SUD that checks up on…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now