Patient Engagement

Increasing Vaccination Without Changing Beliefs

Article · October 5, 2016

What makes the difference between whether you eat a piece of fruit or a candy bar for a snack? Bike to work or drive? Get a flu shot or forgo the vaccination? Would reading a persuasive message filled with facts about the nutritional benefits of fruit, the health consequences of exercise, or the safety and efficacy of the flu shot change your behavior? Research has shown that behavior is less influenced by attempts to change beliefs and more influenced by changes in the environment that facilitate the choice of the healthy option: for example, putting an attractive bowl of fruit on the kitchen table and keeping the candy in the back of the cabinet, providing bike lanes and easy access to bike shares, and offering conveniently available flu shots.

During the past decade, vaccinations have become increasingly convenient. For example, adults can now receive influenza, shingles, pneumococcal, and other vaccinations without an appointment at local retail pharmacies, many of which are open extended hours and on weekends. Expanding convenient access to vaccinations does not target patients’ beliefs or provide education. Instead, it directly influences vaccination behavior. Interventions that increase vaccination are important because vaccine coverage remains too low for many diseases, and a single behavioral act of vaccination can provide long-term protection against an infectious disease.

Education Is Not the Best Solution

Education often is not the best way to boost vaccination rates. Although it may seem logical that changing beliefs and attitudes about the safety and efficacy of vaccines will convince individuals to get vaccinated, educational efforts have a mixed track record — sometimes achieving desired effects, sometimes backfiring, and more often doing nothing at all.

Education is particularly ineffective for changing the resolute beliefs of individuals in the anti-vaccination movement. Effective responses to anti-vaccinators are certainly an important component to a public health strategy for infectious disease control; however, anti-vaccinators make up a small fraction of the population and are far outnumbered by those who miss vaccinations for less-principled reasons. Interventions directed at other segments of the population, such as fence-sitters, may be more cost effective in terms of the number of additional vaccinations administered per unit cost.

Structuring the Environment to Facilitate Vaccination

Rather than attempting to change beliefs or educate patients, an alternative approach is to facilitate action directly by making vaccination more convenient or by using other techniques to cue the desired behavior. Structuring the environment to make vaccination the easily executed behavior is consistent with behavioral insight–driven policy work, which received recent attention with the 2015 announcement of White House Executive Order 13707, authorizing the first-ever Social and Behavioral Sciences Team in the United States.

Behavioral insight interventions are most likely to work for patients who are already familiar with the vaccine and have a neutral or somewhat favorable attitude toward it but have not made getting vaccinated their top priority. Although these interventions have some boundary conditions, their untapped potential for increasing vaccination rates is substantial and often carries little or no cost.

Recent evidence supports the efficacy of the behavioral insight strategy. A meta-analysis of 29 clinical trials investigating interventions designed to encourage vaccination demonstrated that those that focused on organizational change (e.g., offering vaccinations to patients at convenient times) were most effective, whereas more traditional interventions (e.g., reminders and patient incentives) were moderately effective and patient education was least effective. Thus, although the studies in this meta-analysis predate the behavioral insights movement by a decade or more, they support the conclusion that organizational change to facilitate more effective vaccination delivery yields better results than patient education.

Harnessing the Default Effect

A powerful method for changing behavior is to make the desired behavior the default — that is, harnessing the tendency of individuals to stick with the option that will be selected by default if they do not specify otherwise. In a study demonstrating that the default effect increases vaccination rates, university employees received an email telling them that they could make an appointment for a flu shot (default = no appointment) or that they had been automatically scheduled for an appointment that they could cancel (default = appointment). All patients with a scheduled appointment (including the opt-in patients in the first group who made an appointment and the opt-out patients in the second group who did not cancel their appointment) received an automatic reminder email a few days prior to the appointment date. Vaccination rates were higher in the second group (i.e., those who had an appointment by default).

Although automatically scheduling patients for an appointment does not provide them with any additional information about the safety or efficacy of the vaccine, it does make getting vaccinated slightly easier because the appointment is already scheduled. In addition, choosing not to get vaccinated is now more difficult because it entails either cancelling the appointment or not showing up for a scheduled appointment (which some people are reluctant to do).

Planning Prompts

Influenza vaccination rates are also higher when employees are prompted to form implementation intentions (i.e., “if-then” plans that can lead to behavioral modification). In a recent study, corporate employees received postcards informing them about the availability of free on-site flu shots that either did or did not include a suggestion to write down the day and time when they planned to get vaccinated. Those who received the planning prompt were more likely to get vaccinated. As in the previous examples, this type of intervention does not target a change in beliefs or attitudes about the vaccine. Instead, once formed, implementation intentions work by letting the environment control the behavior. For example, if someone plans to stop by the occupational health department for a flu shot on Thursday afternoon right after yoga class, then the act of leaving yoga class serves as the cue to walk over to the occupational health department.

Simple Steps Can Encourage Healthy Behavior

If you want to convince your spouse, sister, or friend to get a flu shot, you could tell them how safe, effective, and pain free it is. But you will likely be more successful if you schedule an appointment for them or if, when you are out doing errands together, you simply stop by a pharmacy that offers flu shots. Environmental designs that increase the convenience of healthy behaviors such as vaccination are often more effective than educational efforts that target beliefs.

New call for submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Now inviting longform articles

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Patient Engagement
Patients and PCPs Hold Primary Responsibility for Addressing Obesity

Patient Engagement Survey: The Failure of Obesity Efforts and the Collective Nature of Solutions

Patients hold responsibility for their actions, but providers’ approaches to address obesity often fall short as well.

Items from the Shared Decision-Making Process Survey for Elective Surgical Procedures - patient decision aids - decision quality - informed consent

Shared Decision-Making: Staying Focused on the Ultimate Goal

Despite growing acceptance and enthusiasm for patient involvement in their health care decisions, clinicians, at times, lose focus on the ultimate goal of shared decision-making: better health decisions from the informed patient’s perspective.

Kangovi01_pullquote community health workers boom

The Community Health Worker Boom

Practical insights that can help organizations optimize their investments in community health workers.

MD Anderson Cancer Center PAAC Health Information Data Before and After Implementation of New EHR System

Using a New EHR System to Increase Patient Engagement, Improve Efficiency, and Decrease Cost

The University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center saw active participation from patients by encouraging them to document their own health information into a new EHR.

Phrases That Enhance Physician-Patient Communication for Scripps Health Hospitalist Groups

Improving Hospitalist Patient Experience Scores: The Importance of Physician-to-Physician Coaching and Medical Director Engagement

With the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services incorporating patient experience into Value-Based Purchasing metrics, hospital leaders must focus on improving this important aspect of patient care.

DLewis01_pullquote Opening Up to Patient Innovations Like Automated Insulin Delivery

Opening Up to Patient Innovation

Next-gen innovations — by new stakeholders — will need a next-gen regulatory system, and clinicians willing to adapt.

Karen DeSalvo - public health population health social determinants of health expert social services infrastructure

Moving from a Sickness Model of Health Care to One of Well-Being — Part 2

A public health expert discusses the scientific, technological, and financial foundations needed to modernize the social services infrastructure and address social determinants of health.

PROs Associated with Better Top-Box Satisfaction Scores at UPMC

Better Physician Ratings from Discussing PROs with Patients

A UPMC study demonstrates the value of PROs, but finds that physicians need to discuss that information with patients during visits.

Karen DeSalvo - public health population health social determinants of health expert social services infrastructure

Moving from a Sickness Model of Health Care to One of Well-Being — Part 1

The expense of the U.S. health care system is so misaligned from what we need as a country — a healthier population. A public health expert discusses how we can move toward a model that addresses social determinants of health and promotes well-being while still growing our economy.

Different Means of Initiating and Sustaining Behavior Change

Survey Snapshot: Social Support, Whether In-Person or Virtual, Is the Key to Sustained Behavior Change

NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members seek ways to create relationships with patients — but the hurdles are high.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Patient Engagement Survey: The Failure of…

Patients hold responsibility for their actions, but providers’ approaches to address obesity often fall short…

Patient-Centered Care

233 Articles

Patient Engagement Survey: The Failure of…

Patients hold responsibility for their actions, but providers’ approaches to address obesity often fall short…

Patient Incentives

66 Articles

Patient Engagement Survey: The Failure of…

Patients hold responsibility for their actions, but providers’ approaches to address obesity often fall short…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now