Care Redesign

Designing and Implementing Better Patient Experiences

Case Study · June 12, 2018

In an effort to create a “wow experience” for its ophthalmology patients and its employees, salauno adopted a Human-Centered Design approach to define and implement operational activities and facility design improvements.

Key Takeaways

  1. The key phases of patient-centered design are: listen to the patient’s voice, create new ideas to solve their problems, and test those ideas with patients.

  2. Patient experience improvement is not a one-off event or initiative but rather a culture and mind-set.

  3. For patient experience improvement to stick, it is key to focus on implementation and standardization across your health system.

  4. To create a positive patient experience, you must address the other side of the clinical experience coin, the staff experience.

The Challenge

Salauno is an ophthalmology provider with 10 clinics and one surgical center in Mexico, where blindness is the second-leading cause of disability, with cataracts and diabetic retinopathy responsible for most of the cases. Salauno was founded in 2011 as a for-profit company with a mission to eliminate blindness in Mexico through a model of low-cost, high-quality, and high-volume care.

In June 2016, the institution wanted to improve patient experience, so it adopted a Human-Centered Design (HCD) methodology largely inspired by IDEO to define and deliver a wow experience for salauno’s patients, most of whom are low-income and many of whom are let down by the health care system. It then incorporated that methodology into its new surgical center design and applied the same thinking to the employee experience.

The bulk of Salauno’s services are medical consultations, cataract surgeries (for patients who are going blind), and retina and glaucoma services (for patients who are suffering from partial vision loss due to retina and glaucoma illnesses).

The Execution

Salauno’s continuous improvement team began by putting together an interdisciplinary team that included an ophthalmologist, optometrist, clinic assistant, clinic managers, and quality and process personnel. This team worked through the three phases of HCD: (1) Listen to the patient’s voice through ethnographic interviews, patient feedback analysis, analogous context visits, shadowing, and empathy exercises; (2) Create solutions through brainstorming sessions to address the problems identified during the listening phase; and (3) Test ideas developed through prototypes and iterations.

Based on everything we had learned from patients through the HCD process, we defined the wow experience as having three components: (1) Being treated like family; (2) Going through a clear process; and (3) Making a confident and informed decision. Concretely, this involved things like laminated information sheets and explanatory videos for each step in the consultation visit process; change of waiting room seats to a more comfortable model for our elderly patients; visual tools for doctors and counselors to explain diagnosis and treatment to patients more clearly; simulation goggles (now virtual reality headsets) for patients and family members to understand the impact of progression of eye diseases; video tours of clinics and operating rooms to give patients a preview and put them at ease; a process to publicly celebrate successful patient recovery post-op; and in-clinic signage with frequently updated numbers on our clinical experience, including patient and procedure volume.

After 4 months, the HCD development process was complete. Next, we focused on implementation and standardization so that the ideas and concepts would become a standard part of the patient experience. This involved creating staff awareness, training, manuals, audits, and other operational mechanisms to go from theory to practice. We launched the wow experience in October 2016 with a video for all staff, describing the experience from a patient’s point of view, and showed how at each step of the way staff could either positively (wow) or negatively (boo) impact the three components of the experience.

We then created 5 to 10 “standards” for each frontline position; these are reviewed and audited monthly so each staff member gets feedback on how they are doing on key aspects of the patient experience, and consequences are applied if the staff member does not improve performance. We created a rotating group of patient experience “ambassadors,” with one representative from each key area/clinic to continue to push the implementation of patient experience improvements at a local level, report challenges if they arise, and bring new ideas to the table to continually add to the wow experience.

When salauno started designing its new 4,000-square-meter (43,055-square-foot) surgical center, we went back to the definition of the wow experience to see how we could include those ideas in every aspect of the new facility.

We wanted to ensure that the outpatient surgical center would be unlike a typical hospital environment, which is often perceived by our patients as being austere, frightful, and intimidating. For example, in each area where important decisions are made or where we know anxiety will be high, we designed big, bright colorful messages that would help patients make an informed decision. Based on our understanding that every patient visit is actually a family outing, we designed a large patio area with outdoor seating and multiple fountains so that those who accompany our patients have a pleasant space to wait together.

During our patient experience improvement work, we realized that the other side of the clinical experience coin was the staff experience (including clinical and non-clinical personnel). It became clear to us that if we wanted our staff to treat patients right, the staff needed to first feel that they were being treated right. In 2016, we also received worrying results in our employee satisfaction survey. So, we committed to developing a staff experience project and decided to use the same Human-Centered Design methodology and structure. That effort began in April 2017 and was implemented in July 2017.

Once again, with a different multidisciplinary team this time (also clinical and non-clinical staff), we went through the three phases of HCD. Several elements emerged as key to the staff wow experience: (1) Growth and development opportunities, (2) Change management, (3) Staff empathy, (4) Well-being, and (5) Family involvement. With executive-level buy-in, we launched the staff wow through mid-level managers to whom it was presented as a set of leadership tools. We took advantage of the existing ambassadors in each team to push forward the staff-focused agenda as well.

The Metrics

Salauno measures patient experience through the Net Promoter Score (NPS). When the HCD project started in May 2016, salauno’s NPS was 83; in March 2018 the score was up 5 points to 88.

Improving Scores Through Human-Centered Design

  Click To Enlarge.

To ensure consistent implementation, the project also defined several metrics to track standardization of patient experience activities (e.g., staff introduce themselves, hand out information sheets, use visual tools to explain diagnoses, etc.) across the network of clinics. Compliance with the standardization activities is currently at an average of 89% across the organization, which we consider to be good at this stage as our goal is 90%. This metric is reviewed monthly and an action plan is put into place to improve areas or components that are below average in implementation.

We measure staff satisfaction with the Great Place to Work survey, which was at a level of 68.2% in 2016. In 2017, after the staff wow project, the survey reflected an improved staff satisfaction of 72%. We also track secondary measures like voluntary staff churn as an indicator of staff well-being. This voluntary churn was 27.5% in 2016 and 25.2% in 2017.

Where to Start

Through this process, we learned that even if you think you know your patients inside and out, to get started on the road to Human-Centered Design, you first need to observe, ask, and listen. When we were looking at waiting within the patient experience, we weren’t focusing on infrastructure but rather on service. Time and again, however, our elderly patients would mention our chairs when complaining about the waiting experience. We had picked out slick, low, metal, modern-looking chairs. They explained to us that for an elderly patient, they were the hardest, coldest, and most difficult to get out of. So we changed to some much more basic plastic waiting room chairs. Our patients told us it was a huge upgrade for them.

We also learned that during the create phase, iteration is key. It is very unlikely that an idea for a solution will be perfect from the start. It is much more likely that it will go through many iterations. At salauno, we thought it would be helpful to give patients little booklets with information on each step of the consultation process so they would know what to expect. We tried by printing out a few and handing them out to patients as they registered for their appointment. One after the other, we watched them flip through the booklet for a few seconds and then put it away. We realized it was overwhelming as a booklet and didn’t draw them in to look at it right there and then.

So the next day, we printed out just a single sheet for each step and handed them out right before the corresponding steps. Patients looked at it a few seconds more, folded it, and put it away, along with all the papers they already had. We realized that to the patient, this looked like one more thing to read once they got home. So we laminated the sheets. The next day, all of a sudden, we had patients reading the information in the waiting room. It was a small, unexpected change in our initial idea that made it viable, and we only discovered it through iteration.

Perhaps most important, staff buy-in and input through these efforts is key. By involving staff from every level and area in the working teams that develop the ideas from the beginning and creating a team of ambassadors across the organization to push the solutions, you ensure that changes take into account realities on the ground and that they stick and meaningfully change the way the organization works and thinks.

Next Steps

Both the patient and staff wow experiences are ongoing initiatives that salauno constantly works to develop and take to the next level. On the patient side, we are currently developing a mobile application to guide and accompany patients before, during, and after their visit to a clinic, educate them on their diagnosis and treatment, provide patients with a report card of each consultation, as well as make and manage appointments. On the staff side, the wow experience went through an initial rollout and implementation phase and is currently being further developed as part of a larger project to further align the organization’s culture with its mission and objectives.

New call for submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Now inviting longform articles

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Care Redesign
Same-Day Breast Biopsy Workflow at Baylor

How Care Redesign and Process Improvement Can Reduce Patient Fear

Seeing how clinicians take care of their own when they are in frightening situations was the epiphany that led to a same-day breast biopsy program.

Rural Health Care Is Rated Comparable or Worse Across Quadruple Aim Aspects

Care Redesign Survey: Lessons Learned from and for Rural Health

Although care delivery models in rural and urban/suburban areas are distinct, by virtue of geographic density and resource availability, each locale affords lessons for the other.

Comprehensive Intervention Review at Lurie Childrens Hospital - improving patient flow and length of stay

Reducing Length of Stay in the ED

A comprehensive redesign of triage and ED care.

Pumonary Nurse Post-Discharge Follow-Up Note for Patients with COPD

TOPS: Telephonic Outreach in the Pulmonary Service at VA Boston Healthcare System

A nurse-directed intervention targeting veterans who had been hospitalized for COPD resulted in improved access to ambulatory care and a reduced rate of readmissions.

Health Care Quality Improvement Prioritization - Keeping the Focus on the Union of Mission and Externalities

Mission and Externalities: The Imperative for Prioritization

Well-meaning providers will fail to improve the quality of care until they focus on what’s important: setting priorities and dealing with the consequences of external factors.

RumballSmith03_pullquote personalized hospital ratings

Personalized Hospital Ratings — Transparency for the Internet Age

Patient user-determined weights could become a highly desirable feature of future hospital ratings.

Dispersion of Palliative Core Skills via a Train-the-Trainer Palliative Care Mentor Model

Back to the Future?

Restoring focus to palliative care through a train-the-trainer model for non-palliative care physicians.

Rosenbaum02_pullquote tailwinds

Twitter Tailwinds — Little Capsules of Gratitude

We would be remiss if we didn’t constantly and exactingly focus on addressing all of medicine’s shortcomings. But how to balance fixing what’s wrong with holding on to all that’s right?

Zane06_pullquote technology to save primary care

Embracing Technology to Save Primary Care

Adding providers won’t solve the health care crisis — but thoughtfully and deliberately deploying technology just might.

Griffin Myers Head Shot Oak Street Health

Rebuilding Health Care as It Should Be: Personal, Equitable, and Accountable

How Oak Street Health, a full-risk, value-based primary care model and social determinants practice, embeds itself in the community to keep its elderly population, “happy, healthy, and out of the hospital.”

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Mental Health

29 Articles

Stay in Your Lane? Clinicians vs.…

Should physicians stay in their clinical lanes when it comes to behavior change and social…

Coordinated Care

126 Articles

Improving Care by Redesigning Payment

A state-run center of excellence uses benefit design to improve outcomes while controlling cost.

Primary Care

173 Articles

Care Redesign Survey: Lessons Learned from…

Although care delivery models in rural and urban/suburban areas are distinct, by virtue of geographic…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now