Leadership

Survey Snapshot: Good Leadership Requires Organizational Alignment

Insights Report · May 3, 2018

When Yale New Haven Health System decided to move an acute rehabilitation unit out of its location at Bridgeport (Connecticut) Hospital in 2015 to an off-site location to gain space, what helped ease the staff’s acceptance of the change was alignment between executives and providers, according to Ryan O’Connell, MD, Vice President, Performance and Risk Management at Bridgeport Hospital.

“We knew the idea would be unpopular because everyone liked the unit’s existing site, but the decision was unanimous by medical leadership, and because there was alignment and engagement between non-clinical and clinical leaders, there was trust,” O’Connell says.

NEJM Catalyst’s recent Insights Council report, “Leadership Survey: Why Big Gaps in Organizational Alignment Matter,” reveals that while an overwhelming majority of respondents recognize the necessity of alignment between key stakeholders, such as executives and clinical leaders, the reality in their organizations is much different. For most, the degree of alignment is far from the necessity.

O’Connell defines alignment as “a mutually agreed-on common purpose, vision, and goals among employees.” In the survey, this definition ranks second behind “the organization’s mission, vision, and goals are supported by governance, strategy, and incentives,” which nearly half of respondents consider the best way to define alignment among key stakeholders.

O’Connell stresses that alignment does not mean everyone always agrees with one another. “If the CEO of the hospital always does what any physician group wants, that would be poor leadership. Good leadership is being present, understanding, and investing a tremendous amount of time with medical staff,” he says, adding that is where the bond of trust is formed.

Bridgeport Hospital, which has competition from another hospital in town, is studying why patients choose one hospital over another. What they’ve uncovered is the power of physician alignment with patients (as well as physician reputation). In the Insights Council survey, almost all respondents say alignment between frontline clinicians and patients is necessary, and 83% say it exists in their organization.

But managing alignment between clinicians and patients is often not simple, O’Connell says. Because Connecticut is still firmly entrenched in volume-based payment, patients and providers feel pressured to choose aggressive care. Better alignment of payment incentives would move both stakeholders to a shared decision-making model, he believes.

Organizational Alignment Falls Short of What Is Necessary

From the Leadership Insights Report: Why Big Gaps in Organizational Alignment Matter. Click To Enlarge.

Colorado Permanente Medical Group (CPMG), a multispecialty physician group that provides medical care to Kaiser Permanente members across the state, is focusing on transparency and alignment on strategy, mission, and goals, according to Monica VanBuskirk, MBA, Portfolio Director of Value at CPMG.

“In any organization, you have to be nimble, and that is much easier when you’re on the same page. It’s hard to be nimble when there is rampant misalignment,” she says. CPMG works closely with Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, but the two are separate organizations that have traditionally kept parallel but discrete strategic plans. With fairly new leadership in place — each organization named a new president in 2016 — the two entities now agree on a single strategic plan, a move VanBuskirk believes bodes well for transparency and alignment. The two presidents have embarked on a tour of Kaiser Permanente sites around the region to explain the plan and gather feedback. “Two years ago, I would have said we were 30% aligned. Now, I feel we have doubled that and continue to get better,” VanBuskirk says.

Health Care Organization Alignment Approaches Are Muddled

From the Leadership Insights Report: Why Big Gaps in Organizational Alignment Matter. Click To Enlarge.

Only 21% of Insights Council members say their organization’s alignment approach is formally stated, while 24% say it is tacitly understood. VanBuskirk monitors sentiment toward transparency via a visual management touchscreen that shows what is being done to execute on incentives and strategy and how that is being received by key stakeholders. For instance, an internal survey conducted last year at CPMG showed “frontline clinicians are hungry for executive interaction, something we see as an opportunity for our leadership team,” she says.

A clinical leader at a health system in the South (who asked to remain anonymous) says keeping close tabs on alignment is essential for organizational stability in today’s dynamic, changing health care marketplace.

Using short “pulse” surveys on employee engagement, the clinical leader says she can gauge alignment and transparency impressions from the organization’s nearly 5,000 staff members, asking questions such as “Does my manager give me feedback?” and “Does the hospital follow its mission?” The health system also conducts a more comprehensive survey every few years to assess its status as a “model community.”

As more physicians move from affiliated to employed status, the clinical leader says the organization is learning how to set guidelines and incentives for performance. “If you’re in private practice, you might elect to do X many surgeries a week, but as an employee of the hospital, you have to do a minimum amount,” she says. This discrepancy can cause friction. However, as the health system becomes more transparent with its strategy, goals, and mission, she is confident that alignment between physicians and executives will improve.

New call for submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Now inviting longform articles

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Leadership
Women of Impact Checklist

Lead In: Women of Impact in Health Care on Advancing Equity in the Workplace

Raising the standards of equity and wellness in our workplaces so we effectively advance health for the populations we serve.

Historical and Projected Numbers of Physicians, Nurse Practitioners, and Physician Assistants.

Growing Ranks of Advanced Practice Clinicians — Implications for the Physician Workforce

The number of NPs and PAs is growing rapidly, while physician supply has slowed. This research projects the number of NPs, PAs, and physicians through 2030.

IBM solutions to physician burnout roundtable participants: Christina Maslach, Paul DeChant, Tait Shanafelt, Namita Seth Mohta, Karen Weiner, Edward Prewitt

NEJM Catalyst Roundtable Report: Seeking Solutions to Physician Burnout

An NEJM Catalyst roundtable sponsored by IBM Watson Health brought together four experts, all deeply engaged in reducing physician burnout from different perspectives, to share in a robust discussion.

Pottharst01_pullquote - value-based health care leadership personas

Personas of Leadership in Value-Based Care

The deliberate nurturing of specific types of leadership personas seems to be a critical factor in the success of value-based care organizations.

Few Truly High-Performing Health Care Organizations

Survey Snapshot: What the High Performers Have to Say

NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members from high-performing institutions share their perspectives on what’s working and what needs improvement.

Morris-Singer01 pullquote clinician burnout community-building

Combating Clinician Burnout with Community-Building

Improving morale and reducing turnover with peer-support meetings and shared group email lists for clinicians.

Time Is What Matters Measure Figure D - Time Saved Compared to FY17 Average

Measuring Patient Quality of Life: Time Is What Matters

How Anne Arundel Health System created a meaningful measure for patients and providers.

Little Consensus Over Definition of High-Performing Organizations in Health Care

Leadership Survey: High-Performing Organizations

Health care is rife with metrics and rating systems that purport to differentiate the good, bad, and mediocre. Every clinician and leader wants to be affiliated with a high-performing organization. But what constitutes high performance in health care?

Eisenstein01_pullquote burnout collective action SDOH

To Fight Burnout, Organize

The social determinants of health — and physicians’ sense of powerlessness in the face of them — seem crucially missing from the discussion of burnout.

Framework for Comprehensive Community Wellness

Public Health–Health System Coordination: Upending the Siloed Status Quo

A five-point plan unveils ways that leaders of health care and public health organizations can take action to enhance community wellness.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Leading Transformation

227 Articles

Safety-Net Providers Lead Disruptive Innovation

Improved targeting of resources must be a consideration if we want to ensure health care…

Leading Teams

150 Articles

Lead In: Women of Impact in…

Raising the standards of equity and wellness in our workplaces so we effectively advance health…

Physician Burnout

41 Articles

Esprit de Corps: Turning Vicious Cycle…

Esprit de corps is the single most important indicator in which health care organizations have…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now