New Marketplace
New Risk, New Business Models

My Favorite Slide: Why Five-Star Hospitals May Be More Closely Related to Five-Star Restaurants than Innate Quality

Infographic · October 24, 2016

Five-Star Hospitals: CMS Star Ratings by the Socioeconomic Well-Being of U.S. Hospitals' Home ZIP Code (n = 4,336)

CMS Star Ratings by the Socioeconomic Well-Being of U.S. Hospitals’ Home ZIP Code (n = 4,336). Click To Enlarge.

Affluent areas are more likely to feature gourmet eateries. They’re also more likely to have hospitals that get four or five stars in the new Quality Rating System from the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services. Based on latent variable modeling of 64 quality measures, the rating system is intended to be the culinary equivalent of a reduction sauce, where multiple ingredients meld to create a rich flavor. Whether all of the nuanced dimensions of hospital quality can be reduced to a scale of one to five is subject to debate. However, any gourmand can attest that a good reduction sauce is about the right mix of ingredients and time. As it now stands, the star ratings system has neither.

The ingredients of the star ratings depend heavily on inputs that fail to account for the upstream social determinants of health that largely determine downstream health outcomes for patients from indigent communities, who rely on the nation’s safety-net hospitals for access to the entire continuum of care — primary to quaternary.

Using the star rating data provided by CMS, we evaluated the socioeconomic characteristics of hospitals’ home ZIP codes by the number of stars they’re awarded on the Hospital Compare website. This slide shows a portion of our findings. Evaluated by an area-level socioeconomic deprivation index that measures multiple factors such as education, poverty, unemployment, environment, and income, we found that one-star hospitals reside in ZIP codes that are nearly three rungs lower on the SES ladder than five-star hospitals. In fact, we found that the socioeconomic health of the hospital’s community grows exclusively with the number of stars awarded, and many of the one- and two-star hospitals are among the country’s elite academic medical centers that treat the most complex patients, who face both clinical and social comorbidities.

If CMS’ goal is to provide an accurate and digestible representation of overall hospital quality and value, it needs to rethink its star rating system. Before regulators try to make the reduction sauce, they need to correct the ingredients to ensure their patrons get the true flavor of quality.


This slide originally appeared in NEJM Catalyst on October 20, 2016.

Call for submissions:

Now inviting expert articles, longform articles, and case studies for peer review


A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From New Marketplace

What Is Risk Management in Healthcare?

Healthcare risk management comprises the systems and processes employed to uncover, mitigate, and prevent risks in healthcare institutions. Understand its purpose, elements, the risk manager’s role, and more.

ED Telehealth Express Care Service Patient Room

Revolutionizing the Delivery of Care for ED Patients

How the NYP OnDemand Emergency Department Telehealth Express Care Service reduced stay times and revisit rates in one year.

Targeting Unconscionable Prescription-Drug Prices — Maryland’s Anti–Price-Gouging Law

Why, in the early 21st century, are so many drugs that were cheaply available in the 20th century becoming prohibitively expensive?

The Economics of Indication-Based Drug Pricing

What would indication-based drug pricing accomplish?

Controlling the Cost of Medicaid

Both political parties should support policies that focus on incentives as a mechanism for improving and sustaining their value.

Resetting the Nation’s Health Care Quality Agenda

Poor measures of care quality have consequences. The National Quality Forum is essential to creating measures that are valid and reliable.

Untapped Business Opportunities for Entrepreneurs in Delivery System Reform

Opportunities for Private-Sector Entrepreneurship in Health Care Transformation

Two veterans of public service say that government can do only so much — which creates attractive business opportunities for entrepreneurs.

Moving Past the EHR Interoperability Blame Game

Why can't EHRs talk to one another? We never created the right incentives, but we pretend that we did.

Emerging from EHR Purgatory — Moving from Process to Outcomes

What's the effect of the mode of physician payment when it comes to EHRs?

Reframing Analytics: Transforming Insights into Action

Centralizing clinical data for an integrated delivery system revealed a surprising lesson: sometimes predictive analytics are not enough.


A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »


Rating the Raters: An Evaluation of…

Some promising innovation is taking place among organizations that rate hospital performance, but major systemic…

Value Based Care

216 Articles

Physician Incentives: Importance of the Why

When moving health care providers forward in the world of value-based care and population health,…

Private Sector Pitfalls in U.S. Health…

Involving the private sector in Chinese health care could be beneficial, but a market only…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now