Patient Engagement

Patient Engagement Survey: The Failure of Obesity Efforts and the Collective Nature of Solutions

Insights Report · September 13, 2018

Analysis of the NEJM Catalyst Insights Council Survey on Engaging Patients in Stemming Obesity. Qualified executives, clinical leaders, and clinicians may join the Insights Council and share their perspectives on health care delivery transformation.

Download Full Report

Advisor Analysis

By Kevin G. Volpp and Namita Seth Mohta

Health care providers view obesity as an epidemic, and many call it a high or extremely high priority at their organizations. Yet clinicians find patients’ engagement in addressing their obesity to be suboptimal. These and other findings from the latest NEJM Catalyst Insights Council survey reveal much about why U.S. society is not succeeding in addressing obesity. Patients hold responsibility for their actions, but providers’ approaches to address obesity often fall short as well.

Patients and PCPs Hold Primary Responsibility for Addressing Obesity

From the Patient Engagement Insights Report: The Failure of Obesity Efforts and the Collective Nature of Solutions. Click To Enlarge.

One of the biggest challenges is patient engagement. The survey respondents — who are clinicians, clinical leaders, and health care executives at U.S-based organizations directly involved in health care delivery — report high rates of obesity among their patients. More than half (53%) say that between one-fourth and half of their organizations’ patients are obese, while another third (34%) say that more than half of patients are obese.

Yet 44% of survey respondents say their obese patients are not very engaged or not at all engaged in addressing their weight. Only 10% describe their obese patients as extremely or very engaged. The rest are considered moderately engaged.

Who Is Responsible for Weight Loss?

Low patient engagement is concerning, particularly in light of the fact that survey respondents overwhelmingly (90%) consider the individual patient as one of the top stakeholders holding responsibility for addressing obesity. This near-universal response reflects the national shift toward encouraging personal responsibility in health care (as we have seen in Medicaid programs and high-deductible health plans) as well as the movement toward patient-involved shared decision-making.

And what of the primary care physician’s role in treating obesity? One might expect PCPs to be considered equally important as patients. Indeed, primary care is strongly represented in the survey, with 89% of respondents saying individual PCPs or PCP teams are among the top stakeholders for addressing obesity.

When it comes to effective strategies for improving patient engagement around weight loss, exercise, and healthy diet, Insights Council members cite provider support (such as motivational interviewing) and peer support (such as patient groups) in equal measure. But we must acknowledge that lack of success in combatting obesity reveals that such approaches are inadequate — either because adoption rates are too low, or because obesity is caused by a complex array of environmental, physiological, and decision-making factors that individual clinicians may recognize but have few tools to offset.

Survey respondents says the biggest barriers to engaging patients in treatment for obesity are the difficulty of sustained weight loss, along with lack of patient perception of obesity as a problem or health issue (both cited by 39%). Close behind is lack of patient adherence to treatments (31%).

In these responses, health care providers and leaders seem to be pointing a finger at their patients. Is that fair? Medical treatments for obesity tend to be ineffective, other than bariatric surgery, which is a big step to take, carries risks, and is not appropriate for all patients.

A Collective Approach to a Big Challenge

How many health care providers do you know who have the time and the training to engage in meaningful motivational interviewing? If we expect clinicians to successfully treat obesity, they must have the right tools. Furthermore, we should recognize that the physician need not necessarily be the clinical team member to interact with the patient in all of these counseling and engagement strategies. While it may make sense to have these activities originate through the physician’s office, other team members are often better-suited for follow-up, such as nutritional counselors. We also should not overlook the potential of technology tools and apps to connect with patients.

Health care providers can play an important role in influencing local and national policy to put in place regulatory changes that support people living healthier lifestyles. This could involve ways to facilitate physical activity or more controversial approaches such as taxation or regulation of food that clearly is unhealthy and contributing to obesity. In written comments, survey respondents bemoan the lack of involvement of other stakeholders to address social determinants of health and a food industry that pushes inappropriate portions of unhealthy processed products.

Although weight loss can be exceedingly difficult, health care providers and patients working collectively and iteratively will have a better chance of reducing obesity in the future.


What is the best way to reverse the obesity epidemic in the United States (e.g., clinical, social, legislative, etc.)?

“Reverse income equality – people have to have the time (viz., not holding down two jobs) and the income tackle obesity. The #1 health problem is income inequality.”
— Director of a nonprofit payer in the South

“Affordable healthy foods; not cheap fast food. Change the perception of obesity; getting to normal BMI.”
— Director of a nonprofit payer in the Midwest

“I think it has to be recognized as a societal health problem. You could almost liken the epidemic to something like polio. You must require government intervention, community service intervention, public awareness, positive incentives for addressing prevention as early as in the school systems, etc. If it is not addressed at all levels, then reversal and prevention will fail. I think unfortunately it will require a large investment in government resources and industry resources to reverse the trend.”
— Clinician at a midsize for-profit physician organization in the Northeast

“I think the education needs to start at a young age to begin teaching healthy eating habits, exercise and stress reduction to AVOID adult obesity. I think insurance companies could offer more financial incentives for those participating in healthy lifestyle activities, such as reduction in co-pays or reduced monthly premiums.”
— Clinician at a large nonprofit community hospital in the Midwest

“Incentivize healthier lifestyles. Possibly through employer engagement. My patients have sedentary jobs, and are struggling to make ends meet. They are very wary of
taking time from work to make themselves healthier.”
— Department chair at a midsized nonprofit hospital in the Northeast

Download the full report for additional verbatim comments from Insights Council members.

Charts and Commentary

by NEJM Catalyst

We surveyed members of the NEJM Catalyst Insights Council — who comprise health care executives, clinical leaders, and clinicians — about engaging patients in stemming obesity. The survey explores the role of various stakeholders both inside and outside of the clinical setting, levels of patient engagement and organizational priorities, and approaches to treatment options and barriers to success. Completed surveys from 725 respondents are included in the analysis.

There is near-universal agreement that both the patient and some primary care representation must be among the top stakeholders with primary responsibility for addressing obesity. Though most respondents identify patients, they are divided on the primary care aspect. Many respondents also call for governmental action and greater involvement by community and business leaders. One physician at a large teaching hospital in the West says, “We need a multipronged approach at individual, family, primary care, and community levels with a few legislative measures.”

Health Care Providers Use Many Approaches to Treat Patients with Obesity

From the Patient Engagement Insights Report: The Failure of Obesity Efforts and the Collective Nature of Solutions. Click To Enlarge.

Download the full report to see the complete set of charts and commentary, data segmentation, the respondent profile, and survey methodology.

Download Full Report

Check NEJM Catalyst for monthly Insights Reports not only on Patient Engagement, but also on Leadership, the New Marketplace, and Care Redesign.

Join the NEJM Catalyst Insights Council and contribute to the conversation about health care delivery transformation. Qualified members participate in brief monthly surveys.

Call for submissions:

Now inviting expert articles, longform articles, and case studies for peer review


A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Patient Engagement
PROMs Usage Is Limited but Growing

Patient Engagement Buzz Survey: PROMs Use Is Growing, but Implementation Takes Effort

While clinical outcomes lend themselves to measurement, quantifying how an individual patient experiences symptoms or a loss of function can be more challenging. One promising approach is the use of Patient-Reported Outcome Measures (PROMs).

Taxonomy of the Patient Voice Table

Taxonomy of the Patient Voice

While health care pursues the important trend of putting patients at the center of care, the terms used to describe this goal are proliferating — and muddying the discourse. This taxonomy attempts to classify some of these terms and make some distinctions.

Agarwal01_pullquote handcrafting the patient experience

Handcrafting the Patient Experience

Health care organizations can take cues from consumer-facing companies like Airbnb to creatively insert convenience and surprise into patient encounters.

Screenshot of Tidepool daily diabetes data

A Taxonomy to Engage Patients: Objectives, Design, and Patient Activation

Health information initiatives will succeed only if they focus on patients’ motivation to engage and reflect the type of engagement they seek.

Ghafur01_pullquote -digital health health care consumer patient experience

Engaging Patients Using Digital Technology — Learning from Other Industries

Providers can benefit patients and disrupt health care by learning from the experience of other industries.

Mission Hospital Virtual Sitter - Drawing of the Virtual Bed Zone and Rails

Reducing Inpatient Falls and Injury Rates by Integrating New Technology with Workflow Redesign

How Mission Hospital scaled a virtual sitter pilot and reduced unassisted falls by 44% and fall-related injuries by 40%.

Health Care Providers Should Incentivize Patients

Survey Snapshot: Patient Financial Incentives — There Are No Quick Fixes

The NEJM Catalyst Insights Council agrees that while financial incentives are a common strategy to engage patients in healthy behaviors, they are not necessarily effective.

Support of Family and Friends Is More Effective Than Clinician Support in Realizing Health Goals - From the Patient Engagement Insights Report: Why No Single Health Incentive Works.

Patient Engagement Survey: Why No Single Health Incentive Works

Initiatives to improve patient engagement come in a variety of forms. While insurers, employers, and health care providers are all involved in using financial incentives and penalties for engagement efforts, improvement in health outcomes has been elusive. Achieving that ultimate goal will usually require a combination of financial and social approaches.

Health Systems Attending the Nudge Units in Health Care Symposium - Penn Medicine

Key Insights on Launching a Nudge Unit within a Health Care System

Leaders are finding that making higher-value choices easier through subtle changes to choice architecture can have an outsized impact on medical decision-making.

Barriers to Providing an Oustanding Patient Experience

Buzz Survey Report: Patient Experience

An independent NEJM Catalyst report sponsored by University of Utah Health on barriers to achieving an excellent patient experience.


A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »


Patient Incentives

75 Articles

Taxonomy of the Patient Voice

While health care pursues the important trend of putting patients at the center of care,…

Ripe for Disruption: Why and How…

For big tech companies like Amazon, Apple, and Google, the health care sector looks ripe…

Patients As Customers

141 Articles

Information Asymmetry: The Untapped Value of…

The knowledge and preferences that patients could — and should — share with clinicians would…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now