Leadership

On Presence: A Tale of Two Visits

Article · December 29, 2016

My husband and I recently found ourselves with his and her ophthalmology appointments — same day, different cities.

Our visits, only 100 miles apart, could not have been more different. The differences, I think, are relevant to safety, access, quality, and satisfaction for patients, and career satisfaction for physicians.

My husband was seen at a regional academic medical center, first by a resident, then a fellow, followed by the attending physician. With each physician, he was aware of how much they typed — furiously typed. During the first few minutes of the visit, each physician discussed the situation face to face with him, with genuine concern. Another few minutes was spent on the slit lamp exam. Then each physician shifted gears. For the remainder of their visits, each was glued to the computer screen. While they typed, the patient felt like an afterthought.

My husband, who is also a physician, wasn’t angry; he felt compassion. Each of these physicians had given up so much of their lives to master their skills, to develop their craft, and to help people in need, and yet here they were spending so much of their time typing, furiously typing, instead of interacting with the patient. My husband wondered how many patients weren’t able to make appointments or see their doctors because so much of these physicians’ time was spent on this typing.

My visit, on the other hand, was at the multi-specialty clinic where my husband and I have spent our careers as general internists. My attending physician did not type much at all. The nurse checked me in, asked how things were going, did standard visual tests, and measured my intraocular pressure. She returned with the physician, who talked with me face to face. While he examined me with the slit lamp, the nurse provided him technical data from my previous visits, and then he relayed to her additional technical data from his exam, which she recorded. He then pushed the slit lamp aside and talked with me again, this time about options and next steps. He consulted previous studies in the electronic health record. But he was not furiously typing. He was talking and attentively listening.

After he left, the nurse stayed behind, provided me with medications, and arranged for a semi-urgent appointment at a referral center. We also arranged for her to check my eye pressure a few times between visits. I know her by name. She knows the details of my situation. We are no longer strangers. I won’t hesitate to call her if a problem arises.

In a word, my visit to ophthalmology included what Abraham Verghese has termed “presence.” The physician and nurse were present to me. And I was a human presence to them. To be fair, my husband was also a human presence to his physicians, but it entailed more strain on their part because of their assigned role in data entry. “Presence” comprised a smaller portion of the overall visit.

Verghese writes of the altered presence the EHR has wrought between physicians and healers:

Being with patients, being present and willing to engage directly in the manner they most want, is a form of risk. The representation of the patient in the EMR (the iPatient, as I call it) is necessary. But being with the iPatient too long is a guaranteed way of not being present with the actual patient. It can even begin to feel safer and simpler to be present with one of the many “enchanted objects” around us — computer screens, tablets, and smartphones — than with human beings.

Verghese makes the case that the central act of medicine is observation, and that the central tool is “the medical gaze.” My husband’s visit comprised a lot of “screen gaze” time. My own had more of “the medical gaze.”

As a physician, it has been the times when I push away from the computer to pause, look, and listen to the patient in which I find the most meaning, the most value. It is then that a missed diagnosis may pop into my mind, an insight into the patient’s hesitation becomes apparent, or simply when the meeting of two people in a room, in a clinic, in a community, on this planet happens.

In his essay, Verghese concludes:

There are a few things that are timeless in medicine, unchanged since antiquity, which we can keep front and center as we bring about reform. One is the simple truth that patients want us to be more present. We as physicians want to be more present with the patient, as well, because without that contact, our professional life loses much of its meaning.

It is a one-word rallying cry for patients and physicians, the common ground we share, the one thing we should not compromise, the starting place to begin reform, the single word to put on the placard as we rally for the cause.

Presence.

Period.

It is our job, I believe, as physicians, administrators, technology vendors, regulators, payers, and even patients, to come together to create the environment where patients and care teams can be present to one another.

This is one of my goals as Vice President of Professional Satisfaction at the American Medical Association: to help create the conditions where joy in practice is possible, where presence is probable. How?

  • At the practice level, by working smarter, not harder. At the AMA we are creating free online practice transformation toolkits to help practices reengineer their work. Advanced models of teamwork allow the mandatory work to get taken care of, but not at the expense of the important work.
  • At the regulatory level, by debunking urban myths and reducing regulatory pain points, so that physicians don’t spend most of their days doing the wrong work for patients.
  • At the technology level, by creating technology that supports rather than hinders healing relationships.
  • At the measurement level, by imposing fewer, more meaningful, and manageable measures.
  • At the institutional level, by making the quality, safety, and financial case for a joyful, purposeful workforce.
  • And at the individual clinician level, to learn the skills of empathy, resilience, workflow optimization, and teamwork that collectively can save several hours per day for many practices.

While my husband and I both received kind, expert care, his physicians were limited in the number of patients they could help by virtue of the amount of their day they spent doing work a non-physician could do.

That semi-urgent referral I mentioned? The soonest I could be seen by a physician I had seen before was 4 months hence. It is likely that he can’t see me sooner because he is spending much of his day typing, furiously typing.

Health care needs to build structures that support presence, both for the patients already on the schedule, and for those who need to be seen but can’t get in.

New Call for Submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Leadership
East London NHS Foundation Trust Non-Clinical Quality Improvement Days Taken to Complete Disciplinary Process

Quality Improvement for Non-Clinical Teams

Administrative QI projects save money, streamline processes, and even improve patient care for the U.K.’s National Health Service.

Physician Clinician Burnout Is Extensive

Leadership Survey: Immunization Against Burnout

Clinician burnout is far from being eliminated at health care organizations, but leaders, frontline physicians, and nurses are joining forces to get to the roots of the crisis.

Fleisher03_pullquote Physicians-in-Training - An Untapped Resource for Health Care Innovation

Physicians-in-Training: An Untapped Resource for Health Care Innovation

Five strategies that can support long-term leadership development and open opportunities for system transformation.

Tait Shanafelt

Beyond Burnout — Redesigning Care to Restore Meaning and Sanity for Physicians

There’s a growing recognition that organizations need to redesign the way that clinical care is delivered to address the national physician burnout epidemic. Measuring rates of physician burnout is the first step.

Sample Testimonials from Fresh Eyes Action Learning Program

Action Learning–Based Leadership Development at an Academic Medical Center

How Mayo Clinic utilized an action learning–based program to foster the leadership skills needed to navigate the changing landscape of health care.

Many Different Definitions of Stakeholder Alignment in a Health Care Organization

Leadership Survey: Why Big Gaps in Organizational Alignment Matter

An NEJM Catalyst Insights Council survey finds that clinicians and leaders do not see eye-to-eye on many aspects of health care delivery.

Physician Coaching Models Interview Large Headshots - Rana Awdish Dale Glenn Ghazala Sharieff Tom Howell Namita Seth Mohta

Physician Coaching Models: Solutions and Impediments

A group of care experience leaders from across the United States discuss innovative physician coaching models at their respective organizations.

University of Utah Family Medicine Residency Program Value Improvement Projects - Practice-Based Learning and Improvement PBLI Milestones Score by Year of Residency

How the University of Utah Prepares Family Medicine Residents to Lead Value Improvement Efforts

A rigorous 3-year program helps physicians focus on improvement through interprofessional collaboration.

Integrating Product Management Education into Health Care - Example of How Curriculum Would Help Physician Tackle Clinical Need in Tandem with Engineer and Business Lead

The Case for Product Management Education in Clinical Training

How can physicians learn to speak the language of innovation and claim a role for themselves within the innovation ecosystem?

Della Lin picture

Lessons in Leadership: Della Lin

How lessons from a concert pianist in timing, audience connection, and intent apply to health care leadership.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Physician Burnout

34 Articles

Leadership Survey: Immunization Against Burnout

Clinician burnout is far from being eliminated at health care organizations, but leaders, frontline physicians,…

Leading Transformation

194 Articles

What If We Treated Mental Health…

How would we react if only 1 out of 10 people with cancer saw a…

Leading Teams

130 Articles

Action Learning–Based Leadership Development at an…

How Mayo Clinic utilized an action learning–based program to foster the leadership skills needed to…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now