Patient Engagement
Capturing the Patient Voice

The Digital Experience Must Also Be a Human(e) Experience

Article · November 21, 2017

Too often in health care, we forget that the patient is at first a human being. Health care speak is a complex language that removes the humanity from those we serve. Terms like patient experience are used interchangeably with patient satisfaction, patient engagement, and consumerism. But the experience of becoming a patient changes the fundamentals in profound ways. So let’s differentiate these terms.

Here, I’ve tried to distinguish and separate the qualities and conditions of a consumer of goods from a patient, which is critical in order to fully appreciate the differences between the two. If we consider a consumer of any other good, they have certain luxuries. They have convenient access when wanted, they manage their own information, enjoy full transparency of costs, and engage from a neutral or positive emotional state. When one enters the Kingdom of the Sick, these characteristics morph — transparency becomes opaqueness, fear rises, and control falters. The very fundamental capabilities and luxuries afforded to a consumer are disrupted. If we can partner more effectively with patients and enable self-efficacy and control, the potential exists for the patient to evolve into an “engaged patient.”

Patient Experience: From Consumer to Patient and All That Comes in Between

  Click To Enlarge.

In other words, becoming a patient is disruptive and life altering. If you had them to begin with, the luxuries of access, communication, control, service, emotional/physical well-being, and transparency erode. At a more profound level, becoming a patient challenges your identity. Your humanity. So the opportunity lies in not only making sure we return these capabilities, but also in ensuring that our patients feel like human beings. Not an iPatient. Not a bed #. Not a disease.

Technology is already radically changing the patient experience landscape. Interactive TVs are rolling out across health care systems and enabling patients to order appropriate diets, cue education, and allow virtual visits with clinicians and perhaps even loved ones — a much different experience than a 1970 TV hanging from the corner wall. The new, evolving use of Customer Relationship Management (CRMs) is also a step forward, prompting us to call patients by the right name, knowing their appointment preferences, and knowing how long they’ve been a loyal patient (getting these things wrong creates not only a bad experience, but also a brilliant “disengagement” strategy). Virtual reality capability is rapidly shifting into a custom-designed virtual experience that would allow them to be “virtually” home with their families or in their favorite place at the end of their life.

These technology innovations drive a different experience for patients based on what capabilities we want to give back — and might make them feel more human. However, many of them are enhancements to existing frameworks; we still round the same way we did 30 years ago, we still have front desks, patients still complete paper surveys, we still have 9 to 5 scheduling templates. If we are to believe, as many of us do, that the caregiver or clinician experience also impacts the patient experience, technology has even more work to do. A frequently quoted study published last year highlights that for every hour of clinical time, physicians spend an extra 2 hours at home completing work. Technology and its designers must appreciate the potential impact they will have in giving back time — and meaning — to our clinicians.

A great example is expediting the log-on process so that we tap and go, rather than spend 30 seconds logging onto the EMR every time we see a patient. Another homegrown solution is a mobile application that allows clinicians to access patient data from their mobile device rather than having to find a computer (or workstation on wheels) to log in. Voice-activated solutions are around the corner, and may move us even further from the virtual scribes or transcription technologies of today. Information itself is being generated at a rate no human brain can keep up with, much less from multiple, disconnected channels. I’m beginning to get excited about throughput solutions that help eliminate waiting, but also better predict who will be admitted, so we can start searching for a bed before the consultant even sees the patient. Solutions like IBM Watson or AI will become most interesting — and not just clinically — when they can help us understand how to best connect with the patients in front of us based on their historical data, appointment patterns, preferences, emotions, and social determinants.

The future vision of health care experience and technology will be in a redesign, a reimagining, of just about every patient touch point. Furthermore, the reimagining must fully appreciate the losses — emotional and tangible — that can accrue when we become patients. Because if you really knew the losses, you would design processes, systems, and communication in a way that gave patients back their power and humanity.

The digital experience will be most powerful when it intentionally enhances the human(e) experience: the uniquely profound experience of feeling connected, seen, known, and valued. The most humane experiences happen when we meet patients where they are by designing the types of touch points they want and need. Of course, there will be places where technology cannot go. Yet, the virtual or digital touch could nonetheless be warm and empathic, if we design it to be so. That touch won’t be the warmth of another human hand in your own. We should hunt for, and preserve, the most intimate of exchanges between clinicians and patients. For me, it’s the moments when I can bear witness to your darkness and suffering, when I can listen, I can cry, I can stay. For my colleagues, empathy amplifiers, and designers, please help clinicians do our required, overregulated tasks more efficiently — or digitize them altogether — so we can immerse ourselves in what we really love, which is, and has always been, caring for humans.

New call for submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Now inviting longform articles

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Patient Engagement

Who Gives Us the Right to “Empower” Patients?

And if we are not truly empowering patients, what exactly should we be striving for?

Patients Welcome IV Self-Care; Physicians Hesitate

Parkland Hospital examines barriers to acceptance of a program that teaches uninsured patients to deliver IV antibiotics at home.

Hawaii Pacific Health Physician Checklist: Creating a Healing Experience

Transforming the Patient Experience Through the Power of Ritual

Ritual is in fact a primitive checklist: a series of steps that create safety and trust between client and caregiver.

Top Three Most Promising Trends to Capture the Patient Voice

Survey Snapshot: Many Different Channels to Hear the Patient Voice

Commentary from NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members on how to capture the patient voice and make hospital staff hear it.

Empowering Patients Empowers Providers

Why should it be surprising and novel that patient-reported outcomes have such power?

Patient-Reported Outcomes for Shared Decision-Making

Making Patients and Doctors Happier — The Potential of Patient-Reported Outcomes

PRO collection is not only feasible and good for clinical care, but it also may enhance physician satisfaction and prevent burnout.

Patient Voice Roundtable Group

Insights Roundtable Report: Measuring What Matters and Capturing the Patient Voice

From a roundtable discussion and NEJM Catalyst survey, a framework for defining the patient voice and integrating it into care delivery.

A Patient and Family Advisory Council (PFAC) for Quality

A Patient and Family Advisory Council for Quality: Making Its Voice Heard at Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center

Though PFAC models abound, metrics on best practices are lacking. One prominent hospital may have found the answer: let those who are the experts at being patients and caregivers lead the way.

Digital Health: USC Virtual Care Clinic

Digital Technology to Engage Patients: Ensuring Access for All

To ensure that we engage the patient groups who have much to gain from the more flexible health care interactions that digital innovation can provide, we must consider issues of computer literacy, access, and trust.

PROMS: Total Knee Replacement - Relief from Knee Pain

Implementing Patient-Reported Outcome Measures

PROMs pioneer shares what’s working in a large health system. Make it easy, make it fast, make it relevant.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Patient-Centered Care

236 Articles

What Does It Take to Increase…

Massachusetts primary care practices are beginning to invest in programs to increase patient engagement, but…

Patient Incentives

67 Articles

OpenNotes, Patient Narratives, and Their Transformative…

The development of standardized tools and techniques are enhancing the ability of providers to interact…

OpenNotes, Patient Narratives, and Their Transformative…

The development of standardized tools and techniques are enhancing the ability of providers to interact…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now