Care Redesign

Survey Snapshot: Design Thinking Is Useful, So Why Aren’t More People Using It?

Insights Report · June 21, 2018

At Navicent Health’s Family Health Center in Macon, Georgia, health care leaders have started to use design thinking to find opportunities for improvement. This past April, they debuted an overhaul to the standard preoperative process, complete with new steps to target patients most at risk of complications.

“We’ve been looking at ways to change the traditional health system responses,” says Harry S. Strothers III, MD, MMM, Chief of Family Medicine at the Family Health Center. “While I would prefer to start from scratch to figure out the best result and design the system to get that result, in most situations you can’t do that.”

For guidance on preoperative optimization, Strothers’ team turned to a nearby hospital, Gwinnett Medical Center, whose preoperative process was resulting in fewer cancellation rates in surgery and fewer holds on the schedule. Strothers has since applied their work to Navicent’s preoperative process in hopes of seeing decreased length of stay, decreased surgical infections, lower 30-day rehospitalizations, and improved patient satisfaction — and they have, indeed, started to see results. “We haven’t been doing it long enough to have statistically significant results yet, however, we are closely watching the trends and will make adjustments as needed per the design-thinking model,” Strothers says.

Stothers adds that their research also showed that the best results came from implementations designed for the local situation; there were no best practices in implementations. Thus, most of the design thinking revolved around explaining the risks of surgery to patients with complexities such as smoking and out-of-control blood sugars, and then helping them with interventions.

“Instead of try[ing] to do PDSA cycles of improvement, we decided to try to design processes that would optimize the patients’ experience and fitness for surgery,” Strothers says. “You can’t convince people to do things — such as stopping smoking — unless they understand the risks and are then given techniques to change their behavior,” he says.

Health Care Organizations Only Occassionally Apply Design Thinking

From the Care Redesign Insights Report: How Design Thinking Can Transform Health Care. Click To Enlarge.

Family Health Center, and Navicent Health System overall, are in the minority of putting design thinking into practice, according to our recent NEJM Catalyst Insights Council Report on the power of design to transform care. Only 24% of respondents say they always or mostly employ the principles and techniques of design thinking at their organization. However, 91% of Insights Council respondents say design thinking would be useful for their organization.

Consensus That Design Thinking Is Useful in Health Care

From the Care Redesign Insights Report: How Design Thinking Can Transform Health Care. Click To Enlarge.

Strothers credits Navicent’s Center for Disruption and Innovation for bringing design thinking to the hospital level. “The CEO understands that it’s important and there are different people within the system trying to use it,” he says. Like nearly half of respondents, Strothers says a limited understanding of design is a barrier, as well as insufficient training in design. “There are only a certain number of people who feel they are good at it, and only a limited number of resources who can help you do it,” he says.

LifePoint Health’s Memorial Medical Center in Las Cruces, New Mexico, also uses design thinking, with the goal of boosting staff member communication to impact quality. Anthony W. Baird, DSc, MHA, CPHQ, CPPS, Executive Administrative Director for Medical Staff and Clinical Quality at the 300-bed facility, and CEO John Harris, helped create the Advancing to Quality Committee to bring leaders together, workshop problems, and affect change.

“Within an hour meeting, we empower employees to put their plan into action,” he says. As part of this effort, each “task” is worked through a color chart of red, yellow, and green to denote that it’s a challenge, is being worked on, or is a success. Participants are given 30 days to resolve each item. Some who resolve their tasks are rewarded with a gold set of wings to wear on their nametag or a silver set presented at a department meeting by the CEO.

One such challenge revolved around fall-risk patients. Initially, the hospital focused on providing different color socks to denote fall risk, but staff complained the socks were not kept in a convenient place. The task force recommended signs be placed in patient eyesight (ground, ceiling, and wall) to remind them or family to call a direct line for help getting up.

“We made a dramatic change in our falls with injuries; the rate is now imperceptible,” Baird says. They also placed inexpensive RFID chips on bed monitors so that those wouldn’t accidentally go home with patients, saving $50 per monitor and ensuring each patient would always have one.

Harris and Baird now have their sights on patient flow, aiming to provide patients with a single badge they’d receive at check-in, which would easily guide them through complex visits that require an exam, an MRI, labs, and more. “The card/badge would contain a unique HIPPA-compliant identifier on the magnetic strip or bar code that would link the registration or scheduling system, [so that when] the patient presents, personal identification would confirm identity. At every turn, their next appointment would know they were coming and would be ready,” he says, eliminating long wait times and redundant paperwork.

“Design thinking starts at leadership but requires empowerment and trust in the people around you,” Baird says.

Call for submissions:

Now inviting expert articles, longform articles, and case studies for peer review

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Care Redesign
Diagram Illustrating the COPD Care Pathway at Allegheny General Hospital

End-to-End Care for COPD Patients that Improves Outcomes and Lowers Costs

Allegheny General Hospital created a comprehensive solution for patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) that led to improved clinical outcomes, reduced hospital admissions and readmissions, and a resultant decrease in the total cost of care.

David Blumenthal and Bob Galvin head shots

Ripe for Disruption: Why and How Big Players in the Private Sector Are Taking on Health Care

For big tech companies like Amazon, Apple, and Google, the health care sector looks ripe for disruption. Two executives working in different parts of the health care ecosystem discuss what this means for patients and doctors, including the positives and unintended consequences.

Top challenges facing chronic disease management care - insufficient time and care coordination

Care Redesign Survey: To Improve Chronic Disease Care, Change the Payment Model

Many health care organizations are reasonably effective in treating chronic diseases, but they are limited from doing better by fee-for-service payment, which remains the predominant payment model in the United States. This report serves as a snapshot in time, showing the intent of health care providers to be proactive in treating chronic disease, but limitations in their ability to address population health.

Nirav Shah head shot Stanford - AI in medicine and team care

What AI Means for Doctors and Doctoring

Physicians must hone the “four Cs” — critical thinking, communication, collaboration, and creativity — when leveraging AI as a new partner in their care teams.

End of Life EOL Palliative Care in the ED for Patients with Advanced Cancer - Process Map - MD Anderson Cancer Center

Patient-Centered Care at the End of Life in the ED

How MD Anderson Cancer Center is improving end-of-life care in an unlikely place: the emergency department.

Home-Based Cardiac Rehab - An Overview from Kaiser Permanente Southern California

Saving Lives with Virtual Cardiac Rehabilitation

Collaboration and innovation can improve the performance of cardiac rehabilitation.

Murali01_pullquote Home Recovery Care patient satisfaction

No Place Like Home: Bringing Inpatient Care to the Patient

Providing home-based acute care improves patient satisfaction and care quality while reducing costs.

Rating the Raters - Strengths and Weaknesses Assessment of the Four Public Hospital Quality Rating Systems - 2a

Rating the Raters: An Evaluation of Publicly Reported Hospital Quality Rating Systems

Some promising innovation is taking place among organizations that rate hospital performance, but major systemic change is needed in the field to ensure access to meaningful comparisons through better data and relevant metrics, and to establish integrated oversight through robust audits and peer review.

McKee01_pullquote - the need for coordinated care IPUs for Parkinson's disease

Creating “One-Stop Shop” Care for Parkinson’s

Integrated Practice Units (IPUs) can revolutionize the care of specialty disease conditions, and Parkinson’s disease is a good place to start.

Good Shepherd culturally competent hospice care home visit to the widow of a recently deceased patient

Strangers No More: Culturally Competent Add-On Programs for Diverse Seniors

Creating specialized culturally competent programs to improve patient satisfaction and address the unique health care needs of older immigrants.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Design Thinking

19 Articles

Handcrafting the Patient Experience

Health care organizations can take cues from consumer-facing companies like Airbnb to creatively insert convenience…

Ripe for Disruption: Why and How…

For big tech companies like Amazon, Apple, and Google, the health care sector looks ripe…

Care Redesign Survey: To Improve Chronic…

Many health care organizations are reasonably effective in treating chronic diseases, but they are limited…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now