Care Redesign
Integrating Mental, Social, and Physical Health

Decreasing the Cost of Care by Avoiding Illness

Article · February 13, 2018

Lengthening Life Expectancy: Improving Health and Decreasing Health Care with the Blue Zones Project

Ben Franklin’s adage that “An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure” originally referred to fire safety but now is most applicable to our nation’s health. Keeping people healthy by encouraging wellness and healthy behaviors has many tangible benefits, including improved productivity, lower costs, increased happiness, and longer life expectancy.  Eighty percent of Americans consume very little health care and, according to the World Health Organization,  80% of illnesses are self-induced. As 5% of the population consumes 50% of the nation’s health care resources, successfully decreasing the rate of self-induced illness by making the healthy choice the easy choice will have a profoundly positive effect on health care and the overall economy.

NCH Healthcare System is a nonprofit integrated health care organization based in southwest Florida with the mission of helping our employees and community live longer, happier, healthier lives. As part of our effort to improve health and add life expectancy, NCH, along with 3.3 million people from 45 communities in 9 states, is currently leading a well-being initiative known as the Blue Zones Project. The goal of the Blue Zones Project is to improve health by preventing self-induced illness. Changing the focus of the health care industry from sickness to health (i.e., from a “repair shop mentality” to a “prevention program”) makes perfect sense if we wish to decrease the burden of illness for our nation.

NCH’s Change of Culture

Helping our entire community to become healthier started with ourselves. In 2009, NCH had a typical self-funded health insurance plan that emphasized coverage for sickness and lacked proactive wellness prevention. NCH’s previous mission had been similar to that of most national health care organizations — that is, to treat disease and collect reimbursement. During that time period, we had the sad experience of having three nurses with breast cancer whose commonality was that they were not getting appropriate mammography screening and therefore had bad outcomes.

Thus, we implemented a new plan. Among other changes, we followed the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force’s recommended screening guidelines for primary care practice and found that a surprising number of individuals had undiagnosed conditions, including breast and colon cancer, prediabetes, hypertension, and metabolic syndrome. Early discovery and prompt treatment changed prognoses for the better, with a 2% reduction in high-risk BMI since 2009. Although we initially noticed a spike in cost for the treatment of occult diseases, we subsequently noted a marked decrease in costs as patients were screened and treated earlier.

One of other the changes that we implemented during this period was a tobacco policy update in 2009 that named NCH as a smoke-free campus, followed by another update in 2011 mandating that NCH would no longer hire smokers. NCH continues to see a drop in its employee smoking rate, which fell from 2.8% in 2015 to 1.3% in 2016. In comparison, the smoking rate in Florida during the same time frame was 15.8%.

Ending the Repair Shop and Growing a Community’s Health and Well-Being

Motivated by our experience, we wanted to codify our changes and learn how to encourage these good behaviors within the community that we serve. As community care was not one of our core competencies, we searched for an affordable program that had demonstrated objective success on the basis of valid metrics. After evaluating various programs, we selected the Blue Zones Project in 2013. That same year, NCH became the sponsor of the very successful Blue Zones Project for Southwest Florida, and, in both 2015–2016 and 2016–17, our community was recognized as the healthiest and happiest community in the nation, adding 0.2 year of life expectancy during the latter period. This trend is unique in America: sadly, for the first time since 1963, the nation’s overall life expectancy has decreased for the past 2 years.

Blue Zones Certification

In 2017, NCH Healthcare System became the first Certified Blue Zones Worksite in Florida and the first health care system in the nation to earn such certification. Blue Zones Worksite Certification signifies that an employer has made demonstrable and measurable improvements in the well-being of its employee population. To validate the impact of those improvements, we reviewed several key metrics. These metrics were reviewed before Blue Zones Project work began and again after all standard requirements and best practices had been completed and validated. To reach certification, NCH Healthcare System had to maintain or improve scores in its Gallup-Sharecare Well-Being 5 aggregate score as well as in 17 specific metrics.

Employee Health and Wellness Metrics:

  • Sales of sugar-sweetened beverages
  • Number of workdays lost related to any and all types of injuries from fiscal year 2015 to 2016
  • BMI
  • Blood pressure
  • Blood lipids
  • HbA1c
  • Risk status of plan members
  • Nutrition score
  • Depression score
  • Physical activity score
  • Personal health assessment wellness score
  • Stress
  • Critical value report
  • Per-member per-month costs for inpatient, outpatient, professional, or pharmacy
  • Tobacco use
  • Total spend per member per month
  • Total spend per employee per month
Source: NCH Employee Health and Wellness Director

The rate of voluntary participation in our program in the last 5 years is well over 88%.  Following implementation of the Blue Zones Project, NCH saw a 2.8-point improvement in its Gallup-Sharecare Well-Being 5 employee survey metrics between 2015 and 2016. This scientific survey measures the five interrelated elements that have been shown to have the greatest impact on well-being: purpose, social, financial, community, and physical.

According to the national leaders in the Blue Zones Project, NCH has had among the highest annual gains in the overall Gallup-Sharecare Well-Being 5 index. Having positive energy, being encouraged to be healthy, feeling safe and secure, and using one’s strengths to do what one does best everyday are just some of the positive factors that result in happy, engaged, and satisfied colleagues and families. “In the last 7 days, you have worried about money,” was the only worsening metric, which we will be addressing with educational courses. Other very positive trends from 2015 to 2016 are highlighted below.

2015 and 2016 Gallup Sharecare Well-Being 5 Key Metrics Data for NCH Healthcare System Blue Zones Project Life Expectancy

  Click To Enlarge.

Financial Success

The costs for healthier people are lower, which makes intuitive sense. A 2012 study presented in the scientific journal Population Health Management connected a 1% improvement in population well-being with a 2.2% reduction in the likelihood of hospital admissions, a 1.7% reduction in the likelihood of ER visits, and a 1% reduction in the likelihood of incurring health care costs. Similarly positive findings have been reported by others.

With this in mind, we have instituted economic incentives as a way to encourage our employees to buy down our health plan’s high deductible of $1,500 by participating in various activities such as cooking classes, group exercise classes, walking/cooking teams, financial education programs, parenting classes, and other requested self-help experiences and classes. These incentives have demonstrated successful results: NCH has lowered deductibles by about $1 million per year in the aggregate for employees. An audit of NCH’s financials showed a 54% decrease in health care expenditures over 6 years, most recently resulting in $27 million savings from fiscal year 2013 to 2016. We have not raised health insurance premiums for colleagues for the past 4 years and, in fact, have lowered them for single parents who are already economically stressed.

Spreading an Epidemic of Health and Happiness

Even though our community enjoys the nation’s longest life expectancy or close to the longest life expectancy according to the Institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation, most of the nation is stuck in sickness and sadness as most health care providers continue to perpetuate a repair shop mentality focused on 5% of the population. NCH’s mission is to spread our success with America. For everyone to live longer, happier, and healthier lives, we will need to change our focus from treating sick patients to building healthy people. Moving upstream by preventing obesity, avoiding tobacco, decreasing loneliness, addressing mental illness, and stopping drug addiction early in the development of these noxious forces is much more effective than any later treatment. We are pleased to learn from others, share our best practices, and have others join in success for their communities.

New Call for Submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Care Redesign
How Adequate Are Your Organization's Mental and Behavioral Health Services to Meet the Needs of the Patient Population?

Care Redesign Survey: It’s Time to Treat Physical and Mental Health with Equal Intent

By neglecting mental and behavioral health, our society has made it virtually impossible to succeed in holistic health, and thus to improve health outcomes.

Optimizing Diversity and Inclusivity Real People Providing Feedback on Precision Medicine Study Design Precision Medicine Initiative for All Community Medicine

Precision Medicine for Everyone

Until we create an environment where diverse patients are considered participants as partners, the goals of individualized research, prevention, and treatment will be unrealized.

Preventable Contributions to Death in USA Public Health Social Determinants of Health Mental and Behavioral Health

Up-Streamism: Health in the 21st Century

With a concerted effort that incorporates principles of understanding, engaging, and connecting with diverse communities, health care leaders can impact patients’ lives early on, preventing adverse conditions and improving outcomes.

Findings from NYC Health + Hospitals ED Care Management Program

Learnings from a Large-Scale Emergency Department Care Management Program in New York City

A CMMI-supported interdisciplinary care team effort helped a safety-net system strengthen primary care engagement and identify unmet needs.

Chronic Treatment Is Not “One and Done”

Clinicians need to adopt a holistic approach to care, particularly for older patients with chronic and comorbid conditions.

virtual visits nonvisit health care

In-Person Health Care as Option B

What if health care were designed so that in-person visits were the second, third, or even last option for meeting routine patient needs, rather than the first?

Innovative Health Care Organizations - Organizational Designs for Innovation

Small Improvements versus Care Redesign: Can Your Organization Juggle Both?

What are the best ways to introduce innovation capacity into your organization?

Key Recommendations from the National Academy of Medicine Applicable to Health and Social Services Professionals

Creating Healthy Communities after Disasters

Recommendations for health and social service professionals to translate the compassion generated by aftereffects of natural disasters into tangible actions applicable to their own communities.

Family Physicians EHR Use by Time of Day

Infographic: Date Night with the EHR

Studies have found that physicians spend nearly 30 hours per month working on the EHR in their homes — including morning and evening hours over the weekend.

Poor Care Is the Root of Physician Disengagement

When physicians and health care executives disagree over the purpose of medicine, disengagement is the inevitable result.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Care Integration

54 Articles

The “Stranger Effect” — A Look…

Why do miscommunications between teams and consultants occur, and what can we do about it?

Care Redesign Survey: It’s Time to…

By neglecting mental and behavioral health, our society has made it virtually impossible to succeed…

Primary Care

135 Articles

Care Redesign Survey: It’s Time to…

By neglecting mental and behavioral health, our society has made it virtually impossible to succeed…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now