Leadership

Leadership Survey: Physicians Come First in Achieving Change

Insights Report · August 11, 2016

Analysis of the first NEJM Catalyst Insights Council survey on the Leadership theme. Qualified executives, clinical leaders, and clinicians may join the Insights Council and share their perspectives on health care delivery transformation.

 

The journey from fee-for-service to value-based payments is going to require buy-in from everyone on the health care continuum. But who will be the most important stakeholders?

Physicians, according to 81% of participants in the first NEJM Catalyst Leadership Insights Council survey, are the most important stakeholders. Surprisingly, patients, who are supposed to be the epicenter of this evolving marketplace, are named the most important stakeholders by only 58% of Council respondents.

Most Important Stakeholders in Response to Evolving Marketplace

Leadership Insights Report. Click To Enlarge.

This survey was designed to assess the drivers of change in health care delivery, how well they are being addressed by leaders, and the skills and resources needed in this evolving health care landscape.

We are at an inflection point in the health care economy. Approximately 10,000 Americans a day are turning 65, causing a sizable swing from commercial insurance to government benefits providing coverage to citizens.

Reflecting this shift, the NEJM Catalyst survey ranks payment shifts as the biggest driver of change in the health care marketplace. Just over two-thirds (64%) of Council members say it is the most important driver. Council members from the Midwest score it even higher, at 75%.

Most Important Drivers of Change in Health Care Marketplace

Leadership Insights Report. Click To Enlarge.

Physician Fatigue with Fee-for-Service

Yet the predominant reimbursement schema today is still fee-for-service, and providers are frustrated because this system doesn’t give them the results or the incentives they want. Many physicians are facing low, even single-digit, profit margins. They have no wiggle room in these margins and risk going under. While some physicians are retiring as a result, others are joining hospitals or physician groups to reduce their risk. Still others are waiting for value-based payment to catch up.

The industry is anxious for change, as physician burnout rates rise. Researchers at the Mayo Clinic and the American Medical Association found that 54% of physicians suffered from burnout in 2014, a 10% increase since 2011. An author of the study from the Mayo Clinic, Tait Shanafelt, MD, said, “Burnout manifests as emotional exhaustion, loss of meaning in work, and feelings of ineffectiveness. What we found is that more physicians in almost every specialty are feeling this way and that’s not good for them, their families, the medical profession, or patients.”

Some good news is that health care’s migration toward a more team-based approach will ease the stress. Almost half of NEJM Catalyst survey respondents (47%) say care delivery model transformation ranks as the second most important driver of change.

VERBATIM COMMENTS FROM SURVEY RESPONDENTS

What important actions has your organization’s leadership team overlooked in responding to the evolving health care marketplace?

“The loss of joy in the practice of medicine and, the acceptance of the definition of quality health care by insurers.”
— Clinician at a physician organization in New England

“Recruiting and developing analytical talent.”
— Vice President of a large nonprofit health system in the Mid-Atlantic

“Measurement tools to monitor patient outcomes. De-emphasize volume and keep track of patient outcomes. Recognition of non-physician aids to improving patient outcomes.”
— Clinical Leader and Service Line Director at an academic hospital in the Midwest

“Not enough attention to supporting mature physicians.”
— Physician at a large for-profit health system on the West Coast

“Building communication skills and infrastructure in traditional school of medicine departments.”
— Director of a large academic hospital in the Mountain West

“Not developing necessary physician leadership skills and incorporating physician leaders in key planning and strategy.”
— Vice President of Medical Affairs in the South

“Involvement of the practicing physicians from multiple specialties in responding to challenges. Too much top down.”
— Physician at a large academic hospital in the Midwest

“Leveraging advanced BPM and technology (& integration) skills within the existing workforce, and purposely seeking out these skills in hiring.”
— Executive at a research facility in the Mountain West

“The need for population health management tools to be in place.”
— Service Line Chief at a large nonprofit health system in the Mid-Atlantic

“Everything. Sad, but true; we are 100% reactive.”
— Physician at a small for-profit clinic in the South

The shift to multidisciplinary care teams, which can include nurse practitioners, social workers, behavioral health specialists, and others, is necessary, but it’s not without its own stressors, especially for physicians who were not trained to deliver care in this way. Time and resources must be spent to address the disruption that care delivery models introduce, and to teach everyone how to work together in the best interest of the patient.

Nearly half of respondents (49%) call the extent to which drivers of change are being addressed in their organization “appropriate.” As we move farther down the road to value in the next few years, that number should increase, and the 38% who say the response is “not enough” should shrink. A shift away from cleaver-like cost-cutting that revolves around layoffs and attrition, and toward quality approaches that rationally drive out waste (e.g., Lean and Six Sigma), will also increase comfort with change, in our view.

Extent to Which Drivers of Change Are Being Addressed

Leadership Insights Report. Click To Enlarge.

Already, examples of disciplined transformation are emerging, including at the Mayo Clinic, Virginia Mason in Seattle, ThedaCare in Wisconsin, and Intermountain Healthcare in Utah.

Not surprisingly to us, executives (61%) are far more satisfied than clinical leaders (48%) and clinicians (44%) with their organizations’ response to the evolving marketplace, according to the survey. More respondents in the Northeast (55%) feel their organization’s response is appropriate, compared with the South (43%).

The Right Ways to Prepare for Change

The primary ways that leaders are addressing change are realigning incentives and performance requirements for providers (tabbed by 45% of respondents) and focusing on organizational culture (44%). For instance, instead of scheduling more CAT scans, providers are studying the appropriateness of those exams and the effect on patient experience.

Ways Leadership Team Is Addresing Drivers of Change

Leadership Insights Report. Click To Enlarge.

Although 59% of respondents say the top resource needed to successfully navigate change is data and analytics to inform decision-making, only 25% cite data and analytics as the most important driver of change.

While this might seem like a head-scratcher, it makes sense to us. Rich data is not yet available to most medical centers in this country in a way that is helpful with day-to-day management. And no matter how much data you have, if you’re not equipped to respond through a connected culture — that is, teams — you won’t be able to react appropriately. As bundled payments and capitation take hold and data begins to flow more freely, data will surely have a positive impact on, and be instrumental in, care delivery.

Resources Needed to Successfully Navigate Change

Leadership Insights Report. Click To Enlarge.

Yes, it would be great if health care organizations had moved beyond the need to build culture, communication, and teams, but we’re not yet.

And that is why the physician is the most important stakeholder at this critical time in health care. To get to the patient-centered model, you first need to fix the systemic problems that impact physicians.

METHODOLOGY AND RESPONDENTS

  • In June 2016, an online survey was sent to the NEJM Catalyst Insights Council, which includes U.S. health care executives, clinician leaders, and clinicians at organizations directly involved in health care delivery. A total of 495 completed surveys are included in the analysis. The margin of error for a base of 495 is +/- 4.4% at the 95% confidence interval.

  • The majority of respondents were clinicians (48%), with executives (25%) and clinician leaders (27%) nearly evenly split. Most respondents described their organizations as hospitals (37%) or health systems (16%). These hospitals were predominantly midsized (34% had 200–499 beds) or larger (47% had 500 or more beds).

  • Only 9% of respondents indicated that their major affiliation was with a physician organization. More than a third of those physician organizations tended to be big — 39% had 100 or more physicians.

  • Nearly three-quarters of the organizations (72%) were nonprofit, with the remainder of respondents coming from for-profit organizations. Every region of the country was well represented.

Check NEJM Catalyst for monthly Insights Reports not only on Leadership, but also on Care Redesign, the New Marketplace, and Patient Engagement.

Join the NEJM Catalyst Insights Council and contribute to the conversation about health care delivery transformation. Qualified members participate in brief monthly surveys.

New Call for Submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From Leadership

Data Graphic: Results of the CBO Score on the American Health Care Act

Older, low-income consumers are still the biggest losers under the AHCA.

The Danger and Opportunity of Leading a Hospital

Rising from department chair to Dean, President, and CEO: lessons from Jeff Balser.

Reading List: Dave Chokshi and François de Brantes

NEJM Catalyst Thought Leaders weigh in on the most influential and inspiring texts of their careers.

Lessons in Leadership: What Makes Me Jealous

A social norm among Mayo Clinic physicians to answer their beepers immediately sparks excuses and admiration from others.

Reading List: Bruce Leff and Sachin Jain

NEJM Catalyst Thought Leaders weigh in on the most influential and inspiring texts of their careers.

Data Graphic: Which Patients Win or Lose in the American Health Care Act?

The U.S. House of Representatives passed the AHCA on May 4, 2017. If it becomes law intact, what effects will it have on patients?

Using It or Losing It? The Case for Data Scientists Inside Health Care

Health care needs to “own” its valuable data by investing in appropriate internal analytics functions — or risk ceding these data and their insights to outsiders.

Survey Snapshot: Health Care Leaders and Clinicians Talk About the Impact of the Trump Administration

NEJM Catalyst Insights Council members have strong opinions and expert analyses on the coming years.

Impact of the Trump Administration on Health Care Video Still

NEJM Catalyst Deep Dive: The Impact of the Trump Administration on Health Care

Editorial Director Edward Prewitt and Clinical Editor Namita S. Mohta, MD, discuss what our readers believe is in store for health care under the new administration.

Five Changes Great Leaders Make to Develop an Improvement Culture

Ongoing institutional improvement efforts can benefit from health care leaders who are willing to improve their leadership skills through self-reflection and personal change.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Health Care — A Final Frontier…

Design must move beyond narrow projects and encompass complex systems.

Leading Transformation

130 Articles

Lessons in Leadership: What Makes Me…

A social norm among Mayo Clinic physicians to answer their beepers immediately sparks excuses and…

Leading Teams

82 Articles

The Danger and Opportunity of Leading…

Rising from department chair to Dean, President, and CEO: lessons from Jeff Balser.

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now