New Marketplace 2015

Insights in Detail: Plusses and Minuses of Value-Based Care

Insights Report · June 29, 2016

We talked to executives, clinical leaders, and clinician members of our Insights Council for a closer look at the advantages of moving to value-based care.

 

To convince a health care organization to migrate across the spectrum from fee-for-service to value-based care, leaders have to identify and promulgate the advantages. What will be the big wins for adopting new payment models?

According to New Marketplace Insights Report: Value-Based Payment Gains Traction Amid Active M&A Environment, respondents are tied at 54% on viewing the top advantage as “payers are insisting on it” and as “it will improve care quality.”

“I would have thought ‘payers are on insisting on it’ would have been the top one — period,” says Laurie Gianturco, MD, Vice President and Chief Medical Officer for Health New England, a provider-owned, nonprofit health plan with 200,000 members in Massachusetts and Connecticut.

The pressure being applied by the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services to have 90% of all traditional Medicare payments tied to quality or value by 2018 should be impetus enough, Gianturco says.

But she acknowledges that the value-based discussion is a tough one for many health care organizations. “Hospital systems and providers make money for fee-for-service. That’s not guaranteed in value-based care, and it’s going to be a lot of work,” she says.

In addition, providers will have to take risks and implement evidence-based outcomes and quality measures. “That’s not something they have a strong background in doing,” she says.

Because of these hurdles, she recommends that physicians receive support through the transition. “In these initial [value-based care] models, there is tremendous burden put on physicians. The models are constantly changing, with no proven value to them yet,” she says.

She’s optimistic, though, that value-based care will better align everyone on the health care continuum, improve quality, and control costs.

But Caroline Poplin, MD, JD, FACP, physician at the Arlington (Virginia) Free Clinic, sees a difficult road ahead for physicians because of value-based care. “They won’t have more time for patients; they’ll just have more patients,” she says.

She says the value-based care argument gets complicated when medicine and wellness are intermingled. “What internists like me should be doing is coordinating care . . . not organizing someone’s effort to lose weight.” Wellness efforts can be a poor use of a physician’s education and experience, she says.

The demands of value-based care lead to “a disconnect between the leadership and the clinicians in the trenches,” she says. For example, when an obese person comes in for a cold, a physician has to remember to talk to him about vaccinations and cholesterol, and make sure he is working on his weight and has a living will. “Physicians find this approach much harder and less satisfying,” she says.

Paul Nelson, MD, primary care physician at Family Health Care PC in Omaha, Nebraska, isn’t convinced that value-based care will result in better quality.

“Primary care is not insurable by the standard sense of the word, because so much of what you do is manage uncertainty,” he says.

Nelson, a 40-year veteran of primary care, says there is a lack of connection between the social mandate for basic health care needs and the economic mandate for complex health care needs.

For instance, he prefers to have a registered nurse answer the phone at his practice. “If patients have a change in health, the RN knows who needs to be seen immediately,” he says, adding patients call in a timely way because they trust the RN answering the phone. However, the skill set utilized in answering calls is not reimbursable, according to Nelson.

He thinks new payment models “discount” the primary care physician’s role in health care as well, and that things he can do to help people “are not honored by the system.” Therefore, Nelson has decided to move toward retirement.

One survey respondent, a vice president of practice transformation at a midsized health institution in the South, who asked to not be named, says the retirement discussion has come up a lot. “The quality issue is a personal one for physicians, but there is value in accepting volume measures,” she says.

She wasn’t surprised that only a third of respondents to the NEJM Catalyst survey said that “organizationally and clinically, we are best equipped for” value-based care, because she doesn’t believe most are. While hospital-owned practices will be looked out for and supported by their parent organization, “an awful lot of small practices and solo practitioners might be on the negative payment side at the beginning,” she says.

However, she hopes that insurers will reimburse providers upfront for the infrastructure they’ll need, such as updated EMR systems, care navigators, and access to behavioral health expertise.

“[Value-based payments] are going to hurt and are going to be painful, but everyone has to understand that health care costs were untenable and something had to change,” she says.

Top Advantages of Moving to Value-Based Care

Top Advantages of Moving to Value-Based Care. Click To Enlarge.

New Call for Submissions ­to NEJM Catalyst

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

More From New Marketplace 2015

Predicting the Future — Big Data, Machine Learning, and Clinical Medicine

By now, it’s almost old news: big data will transform medicine. It’s essential to remember, however, that data by themselves are useless.

The Big Tent of Value-Based Care Has Room for Big Pharma

Drug companies must join providers, payers, and patients in seeing themselves as stakeholders.

Caring for Older Adults in a Value-Based Model

Using patient stratification and more primary care visits, Chicago-based Oak Street Health aims to reduce hospitalizations.

Caring for High-Need, High-Cost Patients

Five foundations committed to improving U.S. care for complex patients outline promising program models and keys to success.

How 30 Percent Became the “Tipping Point”

Received wisdom for meaningful change in health care payment and delivery system reform.

Two-Year Costs and Quality in the Comprehensive Primary Care Initiative

Midway through this four-year intervention, participating practices report progress in transforming the delivery of primary care. But savings and improvements in the quality of care or patient experience are lagging.

The Coming Battle over Shared Savings — Primary Care Physicians versus Specialists

The way physicians are organized and reimbursed in the United States is undergoing a once-in-a-generation transformation from a fee-for-service system to alternative payment models. PCPs are well positioned economically and strategically, but specialists must adapt.

How a Pediatric ACO Coordinates Care for Children with Disabilities

Ohio-based Partners for Kids is charting new territory in care coordination for a high-need population.

My Favorite Slide: Transitions in Health Insurance Coverage Type Are the Norm

Age and income play a role in both short- and long-term fluctuations.

Mixed Early Performance of Medicare Accountable Care Organizations

The earliest participants in MSSP contracts reduced Medicare spending, but the second cohort did not. Meanwhile, some quality measures improved among MSSP participants, while others were unchanged.

Connect

A weekly email newsletter featuring the latest actionable ideas and practical innovations from NEJM Catalyst.

Learn More »

Topics

Success and Failure in the Insurance…

Efforts to reform or replace the ACA should proceed with the knowledge that highly publicized…

Bundled Payments

30 Articles

An Image of Medical Complexity

It’s no wonder the general public can’t decode the complexity of health care finance when…

Value Based Care

105 Articles

Focusing on High-Cost Patients — The…

A focus on high-cost patients may not only fail to contain health care spending, but…

Insights Council

Have a voice. Join other health care leaders effecting change, shaping tomorrow.

Apply Now